The Taming of the Shrew is one of Shakespeare’s more problematic plays, to put it mildly. Misogynistic and disturbing, its philosophy on the role of women is brutal and cruel, and I can never encounter Kate’s final speech without cringing.
Still, the tactic of framing the story as a play-within-a-play-within-a-play sets the action at some remove from the audience, and I wonder if this is intentional on Shakespeare’s part. In any case it gave the company at the Globe, where I spent Friday evening, the opportunity to stage a fantastic opening scene. Actor Simon Paisley Day, in the guise of a drunken football hooligan, stumbles through the yard. With security guards and theatre stewards hot on his heels, he clambers onto the stage and falls down in a drunken stupor. Several audience members didn’t seem to realise that this was part of the play. At this point, the rest of the cast appear from the back of the stage and proceed to dress the lout in period costume, in order to trick him into believing he is a nobleman. The bulk of the action in Shrew is staged for his benefit.
The play is performed ‘straight’, without deep insights or radical staging, but Toby Frow’s production brings out the complexities and innuendos in Shakespeare’s words, with every reference and inference marked in some way by the superb cast. Despite my distaste for the chief theme of the play, I found myself roaring with laughter during a great deal of it, even the Petruchio-Kate scenes. During their first meeting they play off one another marvellously, revealing an underlying sexual attraction and warring spark. Samantha Spiro’s rampaging, energetic Kate gives as good as she gets, and it’s a shame that subsequent events subdue her. Simon Paisley Day, now transformed from a boorish football fan into Petruchio, reveals a kind of admiration for her spirit, and I had a certain initial sympathy for his character, as it was hinted that Kate’s fiery nature held a genuine attraction for him.
If it wasn’t for the middle scenes of the play, which see Petruchio attempting to crush his new wife’s spirit, I would almost have thought the final scene, in which he seeks to prove Kate’s new submissive persona, a plot cooked up between husband and wife. It is hard to believe the strong-willed woman of Act One is this meek and compliant creature, unpleasant and torturous as her husband’s treatment is.
The rest of the cast also gave strong performances, particularly Sarah MacRae as Bianca who portrayed the ostensibly meeker sister as sly and self-willed. Pearce Quigley as the glum and slightly subversive Gromio milked every last drop of humour out of a running kicking-the-bucket gag.
This was a strong, highly entertaining performance of a thought-provoking play. I felt slightly ashamed of myself for laughing so hard at the horrific treatment of women, but there is lots of guilt-free enjoyment to be gained from this production too.
Recent Comments