Damned By Despair is the name of the production currently showing in the National’s Olivier theatre, and by the sounds of it, it has left several viewers and reviewers in a state of despair. Unfortunately I bought my ticket before reading the negative reviews, so braced myself for a less than wonderful experience.
A product of the Spanish Golden Age, this 1625 play was written by the monk Tirso de Molina, and is widely regarded as a masterpiece. It tells the story of the deeply religious Paulo (Sebastian Armesto), who has spent ten years in the wilderness, growing increasingly frustrated at the lack of acknowledgement from his God. The Devil (Amanda Lawrence), disguised as an angel, appears to Paulo and informs him that he must go to Naples to meet a man called Enrico (Bertie Carvel); Paulo will go to heaven or hell according to where Enrico ends up. On discovering that Enrico is a murderous thug, Paulo’s reaction is to abandon his life of contemplation and become a hill-dwelling bandit. Ironically, Enrico’s faith in redemption influences his eventual repentance and ascent towards heaven, while Paulo’s pride and anger ends with his descent into hell. As an exploration of morality and seventeenth century religious belief, I thought the play sounded extremely interesting and thought-provoking.
Unfortunately, though there were flashes of excellence in Bijan Sheibani’s production, they were few and far between. The huge Olivier space, not empty by any means but less full than I’ve ever seen it, swamped the play, which did not benefit from Giles Cadle’s minimalist set: I think it would have done much better in the small Cottesloe. I don’t object in principle to setting an older play in a later period, but I didn’t think it worked in this case, with the brown robes worn by the monks in the wilderness looking odd beside the Naples pizzeria and the mopeds driven by gang members. Frank McGuinness’s new version of the play was too self-consciously modern, and rather cringe worthy at times.
The production was a short one, around two hours including the interval, and had been cut by half an hour not long before opening. This made much of the play seem bitty and confusing, and it didn’t allow enough time for exploring the characters’ motivations. Sebastian Armesto in particular, though he gave a good performance as Paulo, didn’t have the opportunity to fully convey his feelings and insights. Amanda Lawrence shone in her role as the Devil, but had comparatively little stage time. I wasn’t impressed with Bertie Carvel: his Enrico wasn’t particularly convincing or threatening, and I didn’t find his character very interesting. My favourite character was Pedrisco (Rory Keenan), whose comic and cynical asides injected some life into the play and, I suspected, appealed more to a modern audience than the two redemption-obsessed protagonists.
I didn’t hate this production, but I certainly didn’t love it. It seemed like an amateur effort, and didn’t make the impact that it should have – in fact, towards the end, I started laughing to myself as the doomed Paulo made an impassioned speech about being “damned by despair”. The use of a young choirboy to represent the voice of God was too sentimental to appeal to me. There was enough good stuff in the production to suggest that the play itself is not at fault, and I’d like to see a different production of it – but this one was a disappointment.
Recent Comments