Bad Jews began life in the UK at the Ustinov Studio in Bath before transferring to London’s St James Theatre. It later embarked on a national tour and a return to the West End at the Haymarket Theatre. I finally decided to see what all the fuss was about, and attended a Saturday matinee.
The comedy, written by Joshua Harmon, is set in a small New York flat in which a young Jewish man, Jonah, is living; he is visited by his cousin Daphna and brother Liam who arrives with his (non-Jewish) girlfriend Melody in tow. The trio’s grandfather has just died, and the fate of a family heirloom is at stake. Which grandchild is most deserving of it?
The play is a fascinating one as it raises questions about family, religion, and cultural meaning. It asks who really owns culture, and to what extent Jewishness – and by extension any religious or racial identity – can define a person. The particular artefact in question has different significance for each member of the family: ultra-orthodox Daphna sees it as a profound emblem of faith, while besotted Liam sees it as representative of love, in particular the relationship of his grandparents. I personally found my own sympathies moving from one character to another throughout the play.
The piece is incisive and funny, making sharp observations about religion, culture and identity. I had originally been slightly put off by the play’s title, wondering if it would only have meaning for Jewish people. This wasn’t the case though: while Jewish identity is important to the piece – one of the reasons for the artefact’s significance is that it played a part in the Holocaust – the play’s exploration of culture, heritage and identity is relevant to anyone and the exploration of family dynamics is honest and rings true, though it has obviously been exaggerated for comic effect.
The play has a fine cast of four: I particularly liked Ailsa Joy as the super-religious Daphna, who managed to be both intensely irritating and hugely sympathetic. The others – Ilan Goodman as Liam, Jos Slovick as Jonah and Antonia Kinlay as Melody – also gave very good performances.
I’m glad I finally took the chance to go and see this play: it was hugely funny but also massively thought-provoking, and the end shocked me.
Recent Comments