I don’t normally review productions I don’t see in the theatre, but I’m making an exception for The Winter’s Tale, which the RSC had orginally planned for last summer but which, after several lockdown extensions, they decided to film instead. Reimagining the production for the screen, but filming it in the Royal Shakespeare Theatre in Stratford, they arranged for it to be screened on BBC4 in April, and it is still available on iPlayer.
This version of The Winter’s Tale is directed by Deputy Artistic Director Erica Whyman, and is set over a formative period of twentieth-century history: beginning in 1953, it flies over the “gap of time” to the late 1960s, a time of great social and political change. The earlier scenes revealing Leontes’ jealousy feature actors in formal 50s suits and gowns, an effective metaphor for the closed and suspicious atmosphere at the Sicilian court, while the carefree atmosphere of Bohemia suits the more relaxed 1960s.
A suitable setting and a promising start: the production, however, didn’t live up to my expectations. Perhaps something was lost in the transfer from stage to screen, but Joseph Kloska as Leontes staring directly into the camera while yelling about Hermione’s supposed adultery came across as hysterical and over-the-top, while the filming-within-filming at Hermione’s trial might have worked on stage, but doesn’t really work on TV. In the second act, Autolycus, the smart-talking pedlar, is simply irritating, while the production as a whole felt rather flat. I wonder if trying to adapt the production for the screen was its downfall: I can’t help thinking it would have been better to film it as theatrical productions are usually filmed, with the camera in the position of the audience and no acknowledgement of their presence.
The production wasn’t all bad: Kemi-Bo Jacobs was impressively dignified as Hermione, and Amanda Hadingue superb as the forthright Paulina. I was also intrigued by the ending, which hinted that Hermione has not forgiven her husband for his earlier behaviour – while embracing her daughter, she barely glances at Leontes.
I remain hopeful that this production of The Winter’s Tale will find its way onto the Stratford stage at some point – not least because I’ve seen every Shakespeare production there since 2012’s Richard II, and it would be a shame to miss this one. But I also feel that making it into a television production robbed it of some of its magic – and I want to see if it flourishes in its rightful home.
Recent Comments