As a fan of James Graham, I knew I had to go and see his new play Punch at the Apollo Theatre. It originally premiered at Nottingham Playhouse before transferring to the West End.
Punch is based on a tragic real life tale. in 2011 Jacob Dunne, a 19 year old from Nottingham, punched trainee paramedic James Hodgkinson on a drunken night out. That one punch killed Hodgkinson. After serving a prison sentence, Dunne was encouraged by Hodgkinson’s parents, Joan and David, to engage in restorative justice. The play is their story.
A hugely emotive subject, I am sure it would have taken Graham courage to write this play, but the Hodgkinsons and Dunne showed even more courage in coming together for the purposes of restorative justice – this is beautifully explored in the play. We first meet Dunne (a superb David Shields) as a young lad, devoted to his hardworking single mother, who grows up and falls in with the wrong crowd. Naïve and thoughtless, Dunne’s descent into violence is not unexpected, and the fatal consequences of his casual punch send him to prison. However, it isn’t until he meets with James’s distraught parents that his real rehabilitation begins. He takes his GCSEs, starts a career, reconciles with his younger brother and delivers a TED talk.
This is a powerful, moving play about the power of forgiveness and true rehabilitation. Dunne must truly confront what he has done and wrestle with the consequences of his actions. Joan and David must let go of their anger and seek to understand the young man who killed their son. It doesn’t let Dunne off for what he did, but it allows everyone involved to move forward.
Julie Hesmondhalgh and Tony Hirst deliver heartfelt performances as James Hodgkinson’s parents, and Adam Penford’s direction effectively moves things along. This is a highlight of the year: a thought-provoking, deeply affecting play.
Recent Comments