I missed out on my chance to see this new play by John Hodge when it first started playing at the small Cottesloe Theatre. However, I got my chance when the play moved to the National’s largest auditorium, the Olivier.
The play was inspired by real life – dissident Russian writer Mikhail Bulgakov wrote a complimentary play about the early life of Joseph Stalin in the 1930s. This nugget of truth has been turned into a satirical fantasy, in which Bulgakov makes a pact with the enemy, agreeing to write the play on the condition that his drama about Molière is permitted to return to the stage. In a bizarre twist, clandestine meetings between the writer and Stalin himself lead to a reversal of roles: Stalin writes the play himself while Bulgakov is compelled to deal with affairs of state, unwittingly influencing the approach of the Terror.
I thought the acting in the play was superb, particularly from the two leads. Alex Jennings lends Bulgakov a dignified, upright but warm air; he portrays the writer’s turmoil and increasing guilt very well. Simon Russell Beale as Stalin was memorable and brilliant. I wasn’t convinced at first: Stalin seemed rather too rural and jovial, but as the play went on his tyranny and ruthlessness became apparent, even more chilling because of his amiable appearance. It was unexpected and unusual, but really worked.
As a satire, the play had its funny moments –the secret policeman instrumental in recruiting Bulgakov to the cause reveals a hidden love for the theatre and revels in directing rehearsals, while the young factory worker living at Bulgakov’s flat jumps constantly in and out of the wardrobe which is his ‘room’. Excerpts from Stalin’s drama punctuate the play, insanely overacted and unashamedly hagiographic.
With its surreal, Constructivist set, the seemingly inevitable arrest and disappearance of most of the characters, and a nightmare sequence in which Stalin chases Bulgakov around his apartment threatening him with a typewriter, the play echoes the writer’s greatest novel The Master and Margarita (and the recent stage adaptation at the Barbican). Unfortunately this was the only reference to that fantastic work, which subversively challenged Soviet ideas and was banned in the USSR. This play leaves the audience with an impression of Bulgakov as a man of compromise who was in the end defeated by Soviet power, while the rest of his work suggests otherwise.
In the end, however, this is an unusual, memorable and brilliant play, which left me thinking about conflict and compromise, even if I didn’t agree with its final conclusion.