Andrew Lloyd-Webber’s The Phantom of the Opera was the first musical I ever saw and remains my favourite theatrical production to this day. It is one of the most famous and popular pieces of musical theatre around, so I was intrigued to learn that a less well-known and rarely performed adaptation of the Gaston Leroux novel, commonly known as Phantom, was going to receive its UK professional premiere at the Ye Olde Rose and Crown Theatre.
Maury Yeston’s score isn’t as dramatic as Lloyd-Webber’s, and it doesn’t grab you in quite the same way, but it is beautiful with many memorable tunes: opener Melody De Paris is one of the strongest. The cast do complete justice to the wonderful music, with Kira Morsley a stunning Christine and Kieran Brown a powerful Phantom. Pippa Winslow makes a brilliant Carlotta, delivering her songs with a great deal of humour.
This adaptation doesn’t stick any closer to the original book than Andrew Lloyd-Webber’s does. Arthur Kopit’s lyrics are generally thoughtful, witty and moving, with only the odd repetitive or duff note. In this production, the characters are given more depth and the Phantom in particular is humanised to a greater extent. Unfortunately this also has the effect of removing much of his mystery and appeal, and there is less dramatic tension in the production as a result.
The set design by Jenny Gamble was, I thought, rather amateurish and weak with the inclusion of a number of cheap-looking props. However, the background, painted to resemble the tunnels beneath the Opera House, was a masterpiece of perspective and I thought it was a shame we didn’t see more of it. Directed by Dawn Kalani Cowle, the show was well-paced and I hardly noticed the time passing, so engrossed was I in the production.
This Phantom certainly isn’t going to surpass Andrew Lloyd-Webber’s masterpiece in my mind. However, taken on its own merits it is a wonderful piece of work and it deserves to reach a wider audience.