Measure for Measure is one of Shakespeare’s more problematic plays, but Joe Hill-Gibbins’ production for the Young Vic exploits its ambiguity and makes the most of its troubling nature. With a stage strewn with sex dolls, numerous video projections, a Mariana who dances to Alanis Morissette and text cuts that bring the running time to under two hours, the production certainly won’t appeal to the purists but it really worked for me.
Miriam Buether’s design, complete with the aforementioned dolls, succeeds in evoking an indulgent and licentious world in which immorality is never far away, even if you sweep the evidence out of sight. The front of the stage is separated from the area at the back, which doubles as a prison for much of the performance, and which we often see via the medium of film. The design, which also contains an image of Adam and Eve, suggests that Isabella acts as a kind of tempter, albeit an unwilling one, to the supposedly upright Angelo.
I thought the cast was particularly strong: Romola Garai was a powerful Isabella, conveying her despair at Angelo’s behaviour and her fear at the loss of her own chastity, mixed with worry for her brother who is condemned to death. She is the first Isabella I’ve seen who truly succeeded in conveying the value her character places on chastity: arousing my sympathy instead of my scorn (as previous Isabellas have done) for choosing this over her brother’s life. Paul Ready was also convincing as Angelo, and the scene in which he tries to physically force himself on Isabella was extremely uncomfortable to watch. Zubin Varla as the Duke suggested a man who is making it up as he goes along, and I liked the use of video particularly in his early scenes, suggesting that his temporary resignation is both a calculated piece of political propaganda and a genuine attempt to transform his own behaviour. He is just as manipulative, in his own way, as Angelo, and to my mind treats Isabella just as badly.
The final scene shows order being restored to the city – but at what cost? The Duke lines everyone up for a photo opportunity but the fixed grins and terrified eyes of the subjects suggests that all is not well. This is the image that this unusual but superb production left me with.