I’m not overly familiar with Stephen Sondheim, but I had read so many positive reviews of his musical (co-written with George Furth) Merrily We Roll Along at the Menier Chocolate Factory, that I decided to go and see it when it transferred to the Harold Pinter. The show flopped on Broadway in 1981, which I find surprising as it’s a strong and powerful piece.
Centred on three friends trying to navigate the fickle world of showbusiness in 20th century America, Merrily is unique in that it tells the story backwards. We first meet the characters in 1973, when successful Hollywood composer Franklin is giving a party. We learn that one of his best friends, novelist Mary, is a drunk and the other, acclaimed playwright Charley, is estranged from him. As if Franklin is running over events in his own head, we see how his partnership with Charley fell apart, his first marriage suffered the same fate and his desire for success has a profound effect on his life choices. At the finish we learn how the three friends first met on a rooftop in 1957, full of hopes for the future.
The show is very clever in the way it delivers this story: I was never once confused as to what was happening. It was fascinating to see how the characters changed and developed. The acting from all involved was superb, particularly Mark Umbers who succeeds in making Franklin a sympathetic character despite his flaws. I also loved Jenna Russell, who in her role as Mary had some of the best lines in the play.
I should probably mention the songs – after all, this is a musical. I liked the music but I didn’t love it, and except for the title track none of the songs were particularly memorable, though several were witty and sharp. Brilliantly directed by Maria Friedman, this is an intelligent show and a strong evening’s entertainment.