Anatomy of a Murder, by Elihu Winer, makes for an interesting theatrical experience when seen at 3Space Hub Blackfriars at Audit House, Victoria Embankment. This site-specific production in an old county courthouse, produced by For Short in association with the Pleasance Theatre, is gripping and involving. Even the extreme heat only added to the sense of place, with fans whirring away in the courtroom to dispel the warmth that was more American than British.
New lawyer Paul Biegler (Benedict Hastings) has a difficult first case: he is called on to defend a Lieutenant accused of murdering the bartender who has supposedly raped his wife. That Lieutenant Manion (George McFadyen) killed Barney Quill is undisputed; what is in doubt is his sanity when he did so – at least, that’s what Biegler wants to try and convince the jury.
I was immersed in the story from the moment of entering the building, taken upstairs by a ‘policeman’ and shown into the bar, staffed by Quill and his barmaid. Along with the other audience members, I witnessed the ‘murder’, although this might have been done more dramatically, I thought. Ushered upstairs into a large long room, we witnessed the gripping first act, as Biegler and his assistant try to grasp the essentials of the case. After an interval, we returned to the room, which had now been set out as a courtroom. Some members of the audience – myself included – ended up in the jury box, which was exciting, though I was disappointed not to be asked to debate the verdict – the ending of this drama can only go one way.
Despite the aforementioned heat I was thoroughly engrossed in the performance, as Biegler sparred with the prosecution lawyer (Matt Jessup) and various witnesses were called and cross-examined. The verdict didn’t come as a surprise to me, but the final twist at the end certainly did.
This is a superb production of a gripping drama, and if you have any kind of interest in crime I strongly recommend taking the time to see it.