On paper, the Old Vic’s new production of Much Ado About Nothing looked promising. Directed by Mark Rylance and starring those two stage greats James Earl Jones and Vanessa Redgrave, how could it not be brilliant? I have rarely been so disappointed in my life.
I should point out that I attended a preview performance, and the show doesn’t officially begin until Wednesday 18th September. However, considering the ticket prices – a meagre £5 off the top three most expensive tiers, and nothing at all off the cheapest tickets – I feel I have the right to expect a show that is as near perfect as it is possible to be so early in the run.
I’ll start with the positives. I think that the idea of making Beatrice and Benedick much older is an inspired one, and it fits in well with the production’s setting. It’s easy to imagine that Benedick is an experienced US army general who meets Beatrice again years after breaking her heart (perhaps during WWI?), bringing an entire batch of American soldiers to a country estate in 1940s England. The lighter scenes work especially well in this context: the night watchmen are reminiscent of Dad’s Army and the capture of the two villains is accomplished by an enthusiastic group made up of two Boy Scouts and a Girl Guide. Mark Rylance used to be the Artistic Director of Shakespeare’s Globe, a venue known for getting the most out of Shakespeare’s humour, and his experience really shows here.
Still, as I’ve said before, when the best bits of a Shakespeare play are the subplots you know there is a problem. For one thing, I hated the set: a bare wood-panelled affair with an open-ended square arch in the middle. Sparse sets can work, but here it just looked cheap and meant that the acoustics were terrible: during the first half in particular, the echoes were dreadful and made many of the speeches almost inaudible. The deep wooden walls of the archway also proved a hindrance during the many scenes in which characters are required to hide. The actors did their best, coming as far forward as they dared, but inevitably there were times when the audience at either side of the auditorium missed what was happening.
Considering they are actors of such stature, I was deeply disappointed with both James Earl Jones and Vanessa Redgrave. I missed out on watching them together in Driving Miss Daisy (on the night I attended, Redgrave was indisposed), so was really looking forward to seeing them work together. However the two had barely any chemistry and lacked energy. I know they are both older than is traditional for the roles but I would have liked to see them a little more animated. I could see hints of potential excellence in Redgrave’s performance, even though she was too subtle and subdued for my taste, but Jones really wasn’t on form at all. Remembering his excellent performance in DMD, I was sad to see that he hadn’t even learned his lines properly, and failed to convince me of either Benedick’s commitment to bachelorhood or his love for Beatrice.
The leads’ mediocrity seemed to have spread to the rest of the cast, many of whom delivered their lines woodenly and without clarity. Notable exceptions included James Garnon as an excellent Don Pedro and Melody Grove as a charmingly flirtatious Margaret. Peter Wight too deserves a mention, playing the highly contrasting characters of Dogberry and Friar Francis with equal skill.
Altogether, I think that there really has been a lot of fuss made about nothing as regards this production. The whole thing felt at best, flat and at worst, amateur – which is actually an unfair slight on the many excellent amateur drama groups out there. I don’t usually like to compare productions of the same play, but I couldn’t help doing so in this case. Eve Best and Charles Edwards at Shakespeare’s Globe, David Tennant and Catherine Tate at the Wyndham’s, and Meera Syal and Paul Bhattacharjee for the RSC all played Beatrice and Benedick so much better.
The best thing I can say about this Much Ado About Nothing is that it might improve as the run continues. Personally, I won’t be going back to find out.
6 thoughts on “Much Ado About Nothing”
Judith Fournel
I couldn’t agree more. This was the WORST performance of Much Ado I’ve ever seen (saw it on 14th Sept) and such a disappointment. It was an insult to those of us who love the theatre (I’ve been going for over 50 years!) and not worth seeing it for nothing, let alone having to pay for such a mess.
Laura in reply to Judith Fournel
It was terrible, wasn’t it! The more I think about it, the more indignant I become that the Old Vic even allowed it to go ahead. I’m just glad I only bought a cheap seat.
paul mcloughlin
I saw it on Saturday 14th (4 days ago) and it was appalling..I described it as mahoganous – wooden, lumpy, dark and tedious…. can’t work out how the huffingtonpost can print a good review…oh unless she didn’t go……
Laura in reply to paul mcloughlin
I was utterly baffled by that review, especially the part where she described the production as “humming with energy”. I’ve never seen a more lifeless play.
Paul in reply to Laura
FYI – I complained by email and received an email inviting me and a guest to visit (as their guests) for another production….. small recompense
Judith Fournel in reply to Paul
My friend & I were thinking of asking the Old Vic for our money back but not sure whether I want to be offered another viewing. I’m wondering what the press reviews will be like. Surely not in agreement with the Huffington post!!