‘The fault, dear Brutus, is not in our stars, but in ourselves’. This Shakespeare phrase, taken from Julius Caesar, inspired J. M. Barrie’s 1917 play Dear Brutus, which is currently being revived at Southwark Playhouse to celebrate its centenary.
A disparate group of individuals have been gathered at the country home of ‘Lob’, a jolly old man who bears more than a passing resemblance to Puck from Shakespeare’s A Midsummer Night’s Dream. At first they’re not sure why they have been gathered together, but as the evening wears on, this soon becomes apparent: they all have regrets, wishing their lives could have turned out differently. In the magical wood to which they are transported, they all have a chance to experience their lives as they might have been.
The point of the play seems to be to bear out the truth of that Shakespeare quotation: that you are essentially the same person whatever path you take, and you will make the same kind of mistakes. It’s oddly reassuring, even if the plot doesn’t always confirm it – one character in particular seems to undergo a complete personality transplant. For most of them, though, it is proved true. The elderly man of the group is just as dreamy in this other life, albeit without the calming influence of his loving wife. John Purdie is just as much of a philanderer as ever, no matter who he is married to. The saddest story thread, though, has to belong to artist Will Dearth, who in this alternate world has a daughter, to whom he will eventually have to say goodbye.
The play reminded me of The Passing of the Third Floor Back, which I saw earlier this month, but is far less saccharine and much more entertaining. In particular, Barrie’s portrayal of a cocky young man is very funny, with a superb performance by Edward Sayer. Miles Richardson’s performance when he realises that his daughter does not actually exist is moving without being overly sentimental. The whole cast generally do a brilliant job. The set, meanwhile, is an Edwardian living room which cleverly transforms into the magical wood by effective use of lighting.
I’m glad I made the effort to see this moving play. It might have a bit of an old-fashioned air, but it’s still well worth seeing.