When both the National Theatre and the RSC announced that they were doing Macbeth this year, I was both excited and bewildered. Don’t theatres ever talk to each other? Still, I was determined to see both productions and compare and contrast. Last night it was the turn of the NT’s version.
Directed by Rufus Norris, this Macbeth is set in a vaguely apocalyptic world where darkness abounds and characters cower in concrete buildings. Yet somehow I wasn’t gripped; I couldn’t muster up any sparks of excitement. For me it fell flat.
Rory Kinnear as Macbeth was unconvincing, and I also struggled to understand his speech at times; I thought he needed to work on his diction. Anne-Marie Duff, Lady Macbeth, was better: I found her conviction believable, her ambition loaded with an undercurrent of sorrow. Stephen Boxer made an impression during his short appearance as Duncan, and I also liked Kevin Harvey’s Banquo, as well as Trevor Fox’s Geordie Porter.
At times the setting was atmospheric and frightening, with the witches’ cackling echoing around the theatre. Sometimes, however, the production seemed to get lost inside the cavernous Olivier space. Rae Smith’s set design is ominous, but lacks interest: too many scenes inside small boxes, and an ugly moving walkway.
Sadly, this production was a disappointment to me: Shakespeare at the National usually leaves a much more powerful impression. I hope the RSC’s Macbeth is better…