This production of Caroline, Or Change, the musical by Jeanine Tesori and Tony Kushner, first premiered at Hampstead Theatre before transferring to the Playhouse Theatre. It’s not a show I’m familiar with, but I thought it sounded interesting, and another point in its favour was that it starred Sharon D. Clarke, a performer I’ve always liked.
Caroline is a black servant in the home of an affluent white Jewish family. It is 1963, the time of the civil rights movement: confederate statues are being pulled down. But Caroline is quiet and hardworking: her anger is all on the inside. Things come to a head when Caroline is told by her employer Rose that she may keep the change she finds in the pockets of Rose’s stepson, to teach him to manage his money better. Understandably, this is fairly insulting given her low salary, and it leads to resentment between Caroline and young Noah, who previously enjoyed a close relationship.
The musical, directed by Michael Longhurst, is very good at exploring the inner lives of all its major characters, including Caroline herself, Noah, grieving the death of his mother and his father’s remarriage, and Rose, struggling to cope with her new life and family. It does feel overlong at times, and the music isn’t always as exciting as I would like. I did like the quirky ideas and characters, including the moon, the washing machine and the dryer, who is represented as some sort of devil.
Where the musical really shines is when Sharon D. Clarke is on stage, alone, delivering her solo numbers with the sort of power and emotion I’ve come to expect from her. She is truly phenomenal and worth the ticket price alone. I also loved Caroline’s daughter Emmie, played by Abiona Omonua, a very different character from her mother, actively fighting injustice and offering hope for the future.
Overall I found Caroline, Or Change patchy, but ultimately worth seeing.