I made a last-minute decision to go and see this play, prompted more by indifferent curiosity rather than genuine enthusiasm. I’ve seen Kit Harington on stage before, so in itself his presence didn’t draw me; I’ve liked, but not loved, Sam Shepard’s plays in the past. Sometimes, though, the shows you approach with a lack of passion turn out to be the best, and certainly I found True West more enjoyable than I’d expected.
Austin (Kit Harington, sporting a deeply unattractive moustache) is a screenwriter, who has sought peace and quiet in his mother’s house in the heart of California. Unexpectedly, and to his dismay, his brother Lee (Johnny Flynn) turns up. Unlike Austin, Lee has embraced, like their father, a life of petty crime, and is soon borrowing a reluctant Austin’s car to go and commit burglary.
What is worse for Austin, though, is that when producer Saul Kimmer arrives to discuss their latest project, he encounters Lee, who somehow manages to convince him that his ludicrous idea for a Western would make a good movie – would reflect the “true” west. While Lee sits down at the typewriter to try and pen his first screenplay, Austin, deeply perturbed by this role reversal, takes to drink and petty crime: stealing his neighbours’ toasters, which he proceeds to set up in a row and put to use. There’s a very funny scene in which he carefully butters a stack of toast which had me giggling over my own breakfast a couple of mornings later.
The two principals are both superb: Harington is unrecognisable from his famous role in Game of Thrones, convincing as the more intelligent but far less streetwise brother. Johnny Flynn as his delinquent sibling is fast-talking and funny, but there is a distinct hint of menace. There are good supporting turns too from Donald Sage Mackay as the film producer who likes Lee’s idea and Madeleine Potter as the pair’s mother, who seems surprisingly unconcerned at their hostile behaviour.
Beneath the humour and the surface plot there bubbles the question, what is “true west”? As the wall rises for the last act, it reveals a desert which seems intentionally artificial. The final irony is that Lee’s film plot, which is extremely far-fetched, appears to become real as the brothers head out into the “desert”, locked in a battle with one another.
A funny, clever play that doesn’t outstay its welcome, it was a success for me.