Boublil and Schönberg’s The Pirate Queen flopped on Broadway back in 2007, and has never been seen in the West End until now. This concert performance at the London Coliseum was arranged to raise money for Leukaemia UK, and the composers contributed rewritten songs and their general expertise to the production.
The musical tells of the life of Grace O’Malley, a famous female pirate hailing from Ireland in the sixteenth century. Fighting for her land and people, she came into conflict with Elizabeth I who sent Sir Richard Bingham to subdue Ireland. The show compares and contrasts two female rulers operating in what was most certainly a man’s world.
While not as instantly memorable as the Les Miserables score, the music has some good tunes and is pleasingly varied: the Irish-set pieces make use of fiddles and penny-whistles while the scenes that take place in the royal court are accompanied by traditional Elizabethan instruments. The lyrics are a bit cringeworthy at times, but I could overlook that. At times I did wonder if there was too much stereotyping going on, as there was plenty of Irish dancing and much reference to clans.
I wasn’t keen on how, too often, the character of Elizabeth seemed to be played for laughs: certainly, her rigid pomp is very different to Grace’s passion, but she shouldn’t be a figure of fun. The story is entertaining with plenty of twists, but I didn’t get the sense of epic scale that I had hoped for: the lack of staging, while necessary here, probably contributed to this. It would be great to see a fully-staged production with a ship on stage.
As Grace, Rachel Tucker was incredible; she really made the production. Hannah Waddingham was also excellent as Queen Elizabeth, and Jai McDowall stood out as Grace’s lover Tiernan. The rest of the cast did a superb job, not least the choir of Arts Ed, whose beautiful voices helped to lift the show.
Overall, a memorable experience, and a definite occasion.