My second visit to Southwark Playhouse in as many weeks was to see John and Jen, the musical by Andrew Lippa and Tom Greenwald. The two-hander stars musical theatre stalwart Rachel Tucker and newcomer Lewis Corday.
The show is an intimate piece about family relationships: it begins in 1985 as young Jen meets her new baby brother John, and the two grow up together, Jen vowing to protect her younger sibling against their abusive father and, indeed, the world. But then tragedy strikes. In the second act, which kicks off in 2005, Jen welcomes her baby boy – also named John – and promises to protect him the way she was unable to do for her brother.
John and Jen spans four decades and explores the complex relationships between Jen and her brother, then Jen and her son. The sibling bond is powerfully explored, at times amusing (as when young John embarasses his sister at her netball game) and at others, deeply moving. Ditto with the mother and son bond in Act 2: the talk show sequence is a particular highlight, which brings out some of the common complaints parents and teenagers make against one another. All the characters are deeply sympathetic: the first John seeking the protection of his sister, the second hoping to get out from under his mother’s thumb, Jen holding on too tightly to her son out of fear she will lose him like she did her brother.
The musical was originally set twenty years earlier and reflected the American political and cultural climate of the time. The writers have updated it with mixed success. The war featured in the show is now the Iraq War not the Vietnam War: it’s frightening how naturally this fits in to the plot, as if the cycle simply keeps repeating itself. On the other hand, Jen’s experimentation with drugs when she goes off to college was clearly meant to be in the context of the ‘Swinging Sixties’ and updating it to the Nineties doesn’t quite work.
The best things about the show are the two performers. Rachel Tucker is one of our best musical theatre actresses and it’s a privilege to see her in such an intimate space as Southwark’s Little auditorium. Her acting is superb and her singing is glorious, particularly in the second act when Jen is struggling with her love for her son, her grief for her brother and the need to let go. Lewis Corday is definitely one to watch. He exudes childlike candour and teenage sullenness at all the right points and holds his own next to his more experienced co-star.
John and Jen is an intimate, moving show that is definitely worth seeing: a powerful story brought to life by two excellent performers.