Blind Tiger’s new adaptation of Hans Christian Andersen’s The Little Mermaid weaves aspects of Andersen’s own life into the fabric of the story, finding parallels in the tragic tale of the famous mermaid. The intriguing production opens with an elderly Andersen (James Earl Adair) revisiting the large house in which he grew up, and encountering a young girl (Jennifer Johnson) to whom he relates the story.
The poor and provincial Andersen spent his formative years living with his wealthy benefactor, Jonas Collin, and became deeply attached to Collin’s son Edvard. However, his feelings were not reciprocated, and the production suggests that his unrequited love inspired The Little Mermaid. These parts of the play were, surprisingly, my favourites, as they put a fresh spin on a familiar tale, and I thoroughly enjoyed Anthony Pinnick’s performance as the shy young Andersen.
I wasn’t so sure about the under-the-sea scenes. The simple set and costumes were pretty and effective, but I got the feeling that the actors were giving way over-the-top performances just because it was supposed to be a fairytale. The little mermaid herself (Claire Sharpe) was irritatingly simpering, and the song in which she trades her voice to the Sea Witch (Erla Brynjarsdottir) was cringeworthy. The only redeeming aspect was Jennifer Johnson’s comedic portrayal of a palace servant.
My feelings about this production were mixed. It doesn’t help that I adore the Disney version of The Little Mermaid and I didn’t think for a minute that this would be better. However, I think it could have been a lot better than it was, although it was partly redeemed by the ‘real life’ scenes with Andersen.