I had never heard of this 1906 play by George Bernard Shaw, but I have seen and enjoyed Pygmalion – twice – so was looking forward to Nadia Fall’s production of The Doctor’s Dilemma, particularly as it was performed in the Lyttelton, National Theatre – I’ve never seen a bad play here yet. It deals with a dilemma felt by newly-knighted doctor Sir Colenso Ridgeon (Aden Gillett), on whether to treat an impoverished but honest colleague or a grasping yet talented artist. Although he recognises the corruption and quackery inherent in his profession, the doctor is swayed himself by his feelings for the artist’s beautiful young wife.
Despite being over one hundred years old, the play feels highly topical, particularly given the threats to the NHS from the current government. Shaw clearly disapproved of private medical practice: in his preface to the play he argued that “Until the medical profession becomes a body of men trained and paid by the country to keep the country in health it will remain what it is at present: a conspiracy to exploit popular credulity and human suffering.” The other doctors of the piece, with the notable exception of Blenkinsop – who has spent his life treating the poor – are vivid examples of this. Peddling their pet theories and cheerfully experimenting on patients, they provide some of the play’s funniest lines, but there is a chilling undercurrent of seriousness: when “ignorant licensed murderer” Sir Ralph Bloomfield Bonington (Malcolm Sinclair) takes on the impoverished artist’s case, the audience knows he is condemned to die.
The characters of the play didn’t have enough depth for me. As far as I was concerned, there was no dilemma: of course the honest and hardworking Blenkinsop should be saved; the artist Dubedat is repulsively selfish despite his obvious talent. On the other hand, the very existence of this dilemma is a criticism of private medical practice – surely all patients should have an equal chance to be treated. Jennifer Dubedat’s character was incredibly irritating: she reminded me of an Anastasia Steele or a Bella Swan, oblivious to her husband’s faults and devoting herself to making him happy.
The play could easily have been shorter: it ran to almost three hours and certainly felt too long. However, it provided much to think about as well as displaying considerable wit and humour. Special mention must go to Peter McKintosh for his superbly designed set, which managed to display a doctor’s consultation room, an artist’s studio, a hotel’s dining room and an art gallery with consummate ease. A worthwhile, if imperfect, experience.