I have seen an amateur production of Martin MacDonagh’s The Pillowman, but was still excited when a West End production was announced. The play was first performed in 2003, and twenty years later it has lost none of its power to shock.
In an unspecified police state, a writer, Katurian, has been brought in for questioning. Her stories, which feature children being treated badly, have drawn suspicion as a copycat killer is on the loose, murdering children in ways reminiscent of these dark fairytales. Tupolski and Ariel play ‘good cop’ and ‘bad cop’, trying to wring a confession out of Katurian, even bringing in her mentally disabled brother Michal to persuade her to speak.
I thought Lily Allen was excellent as Katurian. At the start of the play she displays a kind of middle-class indignation at her treatment, which transforms into a weary despair by the end. I was completely convinced by her performance, particularly her desire to protect and preserve her stories. Changing Katurian’s gender adds nothing to the play, but neither does it take anything away; to me, it’s the performance that matters, not the gender of the performer.
Steve Pemberton was superb as Tupolski, the policeman who takes his job seriously but acts rather impersonally towards Katurian, and Paul Kaye was fabulous as Ariel, the unbalanced and unpredictable cop whose sanity seems constantly on a knife edge. All three characters have complex backstories, despite any appearance of stereotypes. Katurian’s in particular, covered as it is in layers of fiction, makes you understand her point of view and how she is the way she is. Matthew Tennyson is both chilling and fascinating as Michal; the scene between him and Katurian is one of the most memorable of the play.
The main scenes of the play are interspersed with some of Katurian’s short stories, acted out in front of us as Katurian tells us the tale. Ultimately the play is about stories, what they are and why we write them, and how important they are to society. The play’s twisted ending is oddly uplifting, even as it is tragic.