A Strange Loop, now playing a limited season at the Barbican, is a musical with book, music, and lyrics by Michael R. Jackson. Winner of the 2020 Pulitzer Prize for Drama, it originally premiered Off-Broadway in 2019, it was staged in Washington D.C. in 2021 and came to Broadway in 2022.
The musical takes its title from a philosophical concept, and deals with some complex themes, but it’s also funny, sad and heartwarming. The protagonist is Usher, who works as a steward in a Broadway theatre but is trying to write a musical about a black, gay man trying to write a musical about a black, gay man, and is struggling.
We get to see inside Usher’s head as varying characters representing parts of his personality or states of mind come forward and berate him, mocking his appearance, writing ability and lack of self esteem. We also meet versions of his parents, religious and homophobic, asking him to write a gospel play; his agent, hoping for a work with popular appeal; and other industry figures, asking why Usher isn’t writing about racism or police brutality. Usher’s love life is also in tatters, and we witness the brutality of dating apps and an uncomfortable, abusive sexual encounter.
As Usher, Kyle Ramar Freeman has to carry the show and he does this with aplomb. He conveys his character’s warmth and insecurities, and has a superb singing voice. The rest of the cast are also fantastic, switching between characters with ease.
The show is rooted in Black culture, specifically Black American culture, and as such I think parts of it didn’t click for me – but there is still plenty here to admire and relate to. It’s refreshing to see an unapologetically gay, black man take centre stage in a mainstream musical and I admire how nobody tried to water it down for the white gaze.
Definitely recommended – this musical is new and different, and a breath of fresh air.