After a successful run at the Finborough Theatre, Phil Wilmott’s new musical based on the story of Peter Pan, Lost Boy, has transferred to the Charing Cross Theatre. I went to see it, and while I enjoyed it on many levels, it had several flaws which irritated me.
The show, which looks at the characters from Peter Pan and how they fared in wartime Britain and France once they had grown up, is presented as a dream experienced by George Llewelyn Davies, one of the boys on whom J.M. Barrie based his novel. This framing device works well, especially considering the poignant ending: George was killed at Saint Eloi in 1915, with a copy of Peter Pan in his pocket.
Seeing the characters grown up is a fascinating experience, and leads to some amusing moments when Peter in particular has to try and adjust to adult life. The Lost Boys are married businessmen who relax and play only on Friday nights. Bookish John has become a follower of Jung and his younger brother Michael is a music hall performer. In fact, I liked Michael’s character the best of all and would have liked to spend more time on him and his life. Sadly, in this production he is relegated to a minor, albeit significant, role. Wendy, predictably, is in love with Pan and the plot centres around the couple’s relationship. It is both tragic and poignant that Peter gets the Lost Boys to join up and head to the Front, in a dangerous extension of their childhood adventures; it’s also a pertinent comment on the role of imperial attitudes and the promises of adventure that got many young men to join up in real life.
The songs aren’t always amazing, but they are catchy and work well within the context of the show. My biggest problem with Lost Boy was the sexism.
I understand that a musical based on a children’s book from the early 20th century that primarily focuses on a group of lost boys is going to be limited in what it can do with the female characters of the piece. That’s fine. What irritated me was the way the women were explored. The two main female characters, Wendy and Tinkerbell, are little more than stock female stereotypes: the ‘mother’ figure and the prostitute. Tiger Lily makes an appearance, but she does little other than perform a sexy dance. The other female characters, most of whom are nameless, sing a song about how ‘loving a Lost Boy’ means that they have to put up with all kinds of rubbish in the relationship. It’s notable that there’s nothing about how Wendy might be affected by the time she spent in Neverland. The women – particularly Tootles’ wife – do regain some autonomy later in the piece, but it’s too little, too late as far as I am concerned. It came as no surprise to find out that the musical was written by a man.
In all fairness, the male characters are the primary focus of this piece, and there is much to enjoy in this compelling show. For me, though, the sexism bothered me too much not to affect my enjoyment of it.