Watching Jeremy O. Harris’s controversial Slave Play, you come to understand the title’s double meaning. Yes, the play is about slavery, and the impact of that horrific practice centuries later – but it is also about the practice of acting out slavery-themed role plays.
We know something isn’t quite right when Olivia Washington, dressed as an enslaved woman in eighteenth-century period costume, enters, preens herself in the mirror (set by Clint Ramos, reflecting the audiences’s gaze back to them) and starts twerking away to Rihanna’s ‘Work’, seducing Kit Harington’s gruff overseer in the process. Up at the big house on this supposed southern plantation, a bored housewife dominates her mixed-heritage servant, while out in the fields a Black manager gets intimate with his white subordinate.
Ultimately, it emerges that these couples are taking part in role play therapy, discussion of which forms the central part of the play. This section occasionally drags, but it is also sharp and pertinent. Although the therapy has been set up with the primary aim of helping Black Americans, it is the white characters whose voices are the loudest: Alana (Annie McNamara), who found the experience positive; Dustin, who refuses to be identified as white but won’t say why, and Jim (Harington), the only Brit among the participants, who is clearly irritated by all the therapy-speak . Eventually, though, Gary (Fisayo Akinade) passionately pours out his feelings, Philip (Aaron Heffernan) talks about how he feels under the gaze of Alana’s voyeuristic white husband, and Kaneisha (Washington) represses her rage until a powerful outburst at the end.
The last part of the play is really the heart of the whole thing, and spotlights Kanisha and Jim in the privacy of their bedroom as they deal with the aftermath of their experiences and Kanisha shares her intimate thoughts with Jim. It’s an impactful scene, and very difficult to watch.
Powerfully directed by Robert O’Hara, at times the play seems almost too clever and its refusal to provide answers to questions posed is frustrating, if inevitable. The kind of play you think about for a long time after leaving the theatre, it’s an important watch, whatever your race.