Stephen Sondheim sadly died back in 2021, leaving an unfinished musical, Here We Are. Already performed on Broadway, it has finally made its way to the UK and is currently showing at the National’s Lyttelton Theatre.
Sondheim was apparently working on the show for almost a decade before he died. Directed by Joe Mantello and with a book by David Ives, it is based on two films by Luis Buñuel; the first act, in which a group of rich New Yorkers make brunch plans that are repeatedly foiled, is based on 1972’s The Discreet Charm of the Bourgeoisie, while the second, which sees the group trapped inside a fancy house from which the servants have fled, was inspired by 1962’s The Exterminating Angel.
The first act is certainly more cohesive than the second, although its intriguing absurdity too often descends into unintelligibility. It seems to be trying to say something important about the state of the world, the urgency of action and the greed of the 1%, but its commentary doesn’t quite land. Chumisa Dornford-May is a superb actress and singer but her character, Fritz, is too much of a radical left stereotype, while Rory Kinnear, Paulo Szot, Martha Pimpton and the other actors play increasingly dislikeable, albeit amusing, characters. Denis O’Hare and Tracie Bennett are highlights, portraying subversive servants at the variety of locations the idle rich end up in. There is one brilliant moment: the moment when the actors realise that they are characters in a play, and break the fourth wall, staring out into the audience.
David Zinn’s set goes from modern and neon to old-fashioned and cluttered, accurately reflecting what is going on on-stage and furthering the point that this is a show of two halves that don’t really join together. This is understandable given that it is essentially unfinished: the second half doesn’t actually have any songs. Knowing this, the fact that the show is on stage at all is impressive, so it would be a shame to be too critical. The songs that are present show flashes of Sondheim’s brilliance: who knows how good they would be if he had managed to finish the musical?
While memorable up to a point, Here We Are is not exactly a classic. However, I was never going to pass up the chance to see the musical theatre master’s final work.