This year, Regent’s Park Open Air Theatre is staging Lerner and Loewe’s Brigadoon for the first time in thirty years. Always keen to see revivals of relatively obscure musicals, I went along.
First performed in 1947, the rather odd musical saw a couple of game-hunting tourists in the Scottish Highlands dragged back to mythical-sounding village Brigadoon, which only appears once every hundred years. Playwright Rona Munro has amended the story to make the pair American bomber pilots who have crash-landed in the middle of Scotland, and it is strongly implied that Tommy (Louis Gaunt), who is seriously injured, is only ‘saved’ thanks to being rescued by the people of Brigadoon. This aspect, and his fellow pilot Jeff’s (Cavan Clark) sorrow, lend a poignancy to the show that it probably doesn’t deserve.
The combination of World War II and early modern Scotland (Brigadoon has been frozen in time since the Jacobite Rebellion) carries shades of Outlander, but there the similarities end. The songs are enjoyable and rather sweet, but definitely represent a sentimental American’s idea of what the Scottish highlands are like. I tried to get my head around the millions of years a single Brigadoon-year would represent, and struggled. What happens when global warming hits and the lower parts of the Highlands end up underwater? Would the villagers wake up one day and have to swim?
Outside of these musings, I enjoyed the strong performances on offer, from Danielle Fiamanya as local girl Fiona and Nic Myers as hugely entertaining Meg. There is trouble in the form of the disgruntled Harry (Danny Nattrass) who wants to leave the village even though this will apparently doom all of its residents. His fate is treated in a rather blasé manner by the other characters, which really just adds to the odd nature of the show.
The strong performances and enjoyable songs make Brigadoon worth seeing, but try not to think too hard about the plot. You’re better off that way.