I’ve been telling myself for a while that I should go and see some more modern plays, and Death and the Maiden, which was showing at the newly renamed Harold Pinter Theatre (formerly the Comedy Theatre) presented an ideal opportunity. It is a 1990 play by the Chilean playwright Ariel Dorfman, first staged at London’s Royal Court Theatre in 1991 and brought back twenty years later for a revival.
The title of the play comes from the Schubert composition of the same name, played by a sadistic doctor while political prisoner Paulina Salas was raped. The play begins fifteen years after this event, when the former dictatorship has fallen to be replaced by a democratic government, and Salas’ husband, Gerardo Escobar, returns home with the news that he is to be in charge of a committee to investigate the crimes of the former regime. Because of a flat tyre, Gerardo is brought home by the passing Dr. Roberto Miranda, whose voice and mannerisms convince Paulina that he is the same doctor who took part in her rape and torture. She proceeds to take him captive in order to get him to confess.
The play didn’t get fantastic reviews or a huge audience: indeed on the Friday night I attended, the theatre was less than half full. This seemed a shame as it was an absorbing and thought-provoking play that posed plenty of questions. As an audience member I was never sure whether the doctor was guilty or not: the evidence posed could have been the result of his guilt, or of Paulina’s paranoia. The concept of private revenge versus public justice was well explored, particularly in the characters of Paulina and Gerardo who each exemplified one of these ideas. I thought the play seemed particularly relevant to today’s world particularly in the context of fallen governments and allegations of torture.
The play marked Hollywood actress Thandie Newton’s stage debut and she hasn’t received the best of reviews, but I thought she gave a convincing performance. Perhaps she seemed slightly too reserved, but I thought she showed her character’s hurt and anger well. Tom Goodman-Hill as Gerardo also gave a good performance as Paulina’s husband, torn between his love for her and his desire for fair justice. Anthony Calf as Roberto was similarly convincing: from the way he portrayed his character, you could imagine him being either innocent or guilty of the crimes of which he was accused.
The play ended with ambiguity, which I liked, and left the theatre with lots to think about. It is ending its run early, at the end of this year, which is a bit of a shame as I do think it is worth seeing.
Recent Comments