I went along to Southwark Playhouse’s new Elephant site to see Lizzie, a rock musical about infamous American Lizzie Borden, who allegedly killed her father and stepmother one hot summer’s day in Massachusetts back in 1892. As the rhyme goes, “Lizzie Borden took an axe, and gave her mother forty whacks, / When she saw what she had done, she gave her father forty-one”. Many theories have questioned whether or not Lizzie was guilty, but this musical assumes that she was, and focuses instead on why.
One theory, put forward here, is that Lizzie’s tryst with a neighbour, Alice (Maiya Quansah-Breed), was about to be exposed. Another is that she was suffering abuse from her father. One of the most moving moments of the show is when Lizzie sings ‘This Is Not Love’, writhing uncomfortably in her chair, suggestive of her father’s unwelcome presence.
At the performance I saw, Emma Louise Hoey played Lizzie and was superb; her portrayal was defiant yet sympathetic and she had a stunning voice. In fact this was true of all of the cast, including Shekinah McFarlane as Lizzie’s sister Emma and Mairi Barclay as the family’s maid, Bridget. Andrew and Abby Borden do not themselves appear as characters, ensuring that we don’t need to waste time thinking about them or empathising with their plight.
Steven Cheslik-DeMeyer’s score (with additional music and lyrics from Tim Maner and Alan Stevens Hewitt) is rock-inspired and hugely memorable, delivering banger after banger. William Whelton’s direction ensures the pace never slows.
At times I did wonder uncomfortably if the show was glamorising murder, but at others I found I was enjoying myself too much to care. I’m not entirely sure what that says about me, but never mind.
I’m so glad I made the effort to see this: it was a powerful show with some of the best vocal performances I’ve experienced all year.
Recent Comments