Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 originally premiered over a decade ago in New York and it’s taken it this long to arrive in London. Adapted by composer, lyricist, playwright and orchestrator Dave Malloy from a 70-page section of Leo Tolstoy’s seminal 1869 novel War and Peace, it was originally directed by Rachel Chavkin, and here at the Donmar Warehouse by Tim Sheader.
I’ve actually read War and Peace a couple of times (can you hear the smugness in my voice?) but I don’t think the show is really hard to follow, despite the warning in the ‘Prologue’ about the complicated plot and numerous names of the protagonists. ‘War’ doesn’t really come into it, except that one of the novel’s chief characters, Prince Andrei, is off fighting it and barely appears in the show. His absence is actually the catalyst for the whole thing, as his fiancé Natasha is tempted, while he is away, by the villainous Anatole. In the meantime, likeable Pierre, a gentleman, is searching for meaning in his life, which he tends to search for in the bottom of a bottle in a bid to forget his loveless marriage to the amoral Hélène.
I’ve enjoyed some of Dave Malloy’s other musicals, and here he does not disappoint. Blending traditional musical numbers with rock, folk and other influences, his work is wonderfully performed by an on-stage band. Being a sung-through musical, the songs sometimes blend together, but there are still standout moments including “Dust and Ashes”, “Sonya Alone”, and the final number. I imagine this is a score that would reward repeated listens. Leslie Travers’ clever stage design sees the word ‘Moscow’, the city in which the story is set, lighting up the back of the stage, with the first ‘O’ forming a ring that is lowered and raised on stage as needed. Evie Gurney’s costumes cleverly add a modern twist to nineteenth-century styling, and Howard Hudson’s beautiful lighting deserves plenty of acclaim.
I haven’t even mentioned the cast yet. Chumisa Dornford-May is superb as Natasha, reckless and emotionally immature yet likeable and capable of deep feeling. Declan Bennett as Pierre is probably the emotional heart of the story, although we don’t see him as much as I would have liked. Jamie Muscato is absolutely magnetic as Anatole: I am frankly not surprised that Natasha succumbed to him. Maimuna Memon as Sonya and Cat Simmons as Hélène are two of the other standouts for me.
I didn’t love the show unreservedly: I took issue with the one-word, throwaway descriptions of the characters in the opening number “Prologue” (“Natasha is young, Anatole is hot, Pierre is rich and unhappily married”), and at times felt that the show was keeping me at an emotional distance. But the final scene moved me deeply, and the metaphorical image of the comet streaking across the sky as a reborn Pierre looks on will stay with me for a long time.
Recent Comments