The Southwark Playhouse has a strong track record in producing good shows, but this new musical about Phyllis Pearsall, the woman responsible for the London A-Z, doesn’t quite live up to expectations. The A-Z of Mrs P sounded like a good bet, but I wasn’t really keen.
Diane Samuels’ book introduces us to Mrs P, who arrives in London having left her husband, and follows her as she overcomes setbacks and family difficulties to create a successful business. The problem is that Mrs P isn’t particularly interesting. Isy Suttie plays her well, but her singing voice isn’t strong enough to sustain an entire musical. The conflict between her parents – a memborable Michael Matus and Frances Ruffelle – is much more interesting, but the frequent flashbacks and changes in tone are often quite confusing.
Gwyneth Herbert’s music and lyrics are pleasant enough, with a nice line in creating melodies from lists of London’s street names. But there isn’t anything powerful or memorable enough to really lift it above average.
Altogether, a disappointment. Great effort from all the cast and crew, but ultimately I didn’t think this musical truly worked.
Recent Comments