Last night I saw The Pitmen Painters, a modern play which started life in Newcastle before moving to the National Theatre, Broadway and eventually to the Duchess Theatre in the West End, where I saw it. Inspired by a book by William Feaver, it tells the real life story of a group of miners from Ashington, Northumberland, during the 1930s and 1940s that hired a professor to teach an art appreciation class and became, for a brief period, well-known artists.
I didn’t know what to expect from this play, but I loved it. The working class group of would-be artists and their university-educated tutor could easily have been stereotyped – and at the beginning of the play their contrasting personalities did draw several laughs – but the characters all grew into rounded and interesting individuals. Trevor Fox was particularly outstanding as the group’s most talented artist, Oliver Kilbourn, who refuses to turn his back on his friends to accept the patronage of heiress Helen Sutherland (Joy Brook). Ian Kelly, as the teacher who grows to admire and respect his students, and Joe Caffrey as a self-important union official, were also excellent.
The majority of the play was made up of discussions about art. These could easily have been dull, but were by turns funny, enlightening and intellectually stimulating. I felt that I was learning along with the miners, and gained a greater understanding of art in one evening at the theatre than years of school art classes gave me. One of the best parts was the scene in which the painters react to an abstract work of art by Ben Nicholson: their initial bafflement and dismissal develops into understanding and appreciation as they discuss the work.
This political play left me with feelings of sadness. The miners look forward with hope to a brighter future, with the advent of nationalisation and the NHS. We, the audience, know that their hopes were betrayed.
I couldn’t help comparing the play to the film and musical Billy Elliot, also set in a North East mining town, this time Easington, County Durham during the miners’ strike of the 1980s. It was only later that I found out they were written by the same person, Lee Hall. I thought it was very interesting that while The Pitmen Painters was about a group of working class men working together for a brighter future, Billy Elliot told the story of one boy trying to escape from his life – perhaps a sad indictment of today’s society.
Recent Comments