This ambitious production in the new-ish Dorfman Theatre at the National combines three of D. H. Lawrence’s plays into one evening, telling the story of three different mining families. Adapted by Ben Power and directed by Marianne Elliott, Husbands & Sons combines A Collier’s Friday Night, The Widowing of Mrs Holroyd and The Daughter-in-Law into one mammoth tale of love and hardship in the village of Eastwood, on the border between Nottinghamshire and Derbyshire, in the month of October, 1911.
The set is pretty impressive, with plans for the three houses marked out on the floor, capturing the claustrophobic, fenced-in atmosphere. I was sitting in one of the on-stage seats, close to the action, in prime position to gain the greatest benefit from the raising of the steel barrier just before the play started, mimicking the lifts that took the miners into the bowels of the earth to begin their day.
Individually, there is much to admire about all of the plays. Louise Brealey shines as the new bride in The Daughter-in-Law, caught in a struggle with her husband’s mother (an excellent Susan Brown) for his love and attention. A Collier’s Friday Night explores the difficulties that arise when the son goes off to university and leaves behind his mining heritage, and The Widowing of Mrs Holroyd, the only play of the three that I have seen before, is a powerful study of a woman torn between her growing love for a young electrician and loyalty to her boorish husband, with a standout central performance from Anne-Marie Duff.
Having said that, I felt that bringing all the plays together as one was a mistake. The pacing felt wrong, and the tone of each piece had a distinct feel that was lost in the general atmosphere. The dialogue often felt stilted, as it was chopped up and scenes that might have taken a couple of minutes in the original plays ended up taking much longer as all three works jostled for space. Other than allowing some of the characters to cross over from one play into another, creating the feel of a mining community, I didn’t think there was much benefit in this approach.
I would have preferred to see the three plays as separate productions, perhaps performed on the same night with intervals in between, rather than in one combined production. However, I did find enough to appreciate in Husbands & Sons to make me glad I went.
Recent Comments