Best of Enemies, which started life at the Young Vic, has now transferred to the West End. Its author, James Graham, has form in being able to take complex aspects of political history and render them understandable to those – like me – who know nothing about them. His latest work focuses on the 1968 television debates between Republican thinker William F. Buckley and Democrat intellectual Gore Vidal, and examines how they transformed the world of politics in and beyond the US.
Jeremy Herrin’s production, translated to the Noël Coward Theatre stage, immerses you into the late sixties from the start thanks to the music, by the likes of Jimi Hendrix and The Doors, played before it begins and during the interval. The stage gives the impression that you are in the television audience, with the two main characters occupying chairs at the centre while the TV executives are visible through a window above them. I would have liked this to have been further down – purely because I was in the balcony and couldn’t see very well – but the majority of the action takes place at the front of the stage, so it didn’t affect my enjoyment.
The plan to get two respected academics on opposing sides of the political spectrum to debate on live television sounds like an admirable attempt to inform and educate the public, but started out as a cynical attempt by the ABC network to improve their ratings. Graham shows how the debates began, with Buckley and Vidal being courted by members of the network, and how their intelligent “debates” descended into personal attacks and the trading of insults – even as ratings soared. They mark the beginning of a more modern era when personality became entwined with politics. The play asks if these televised debates have improved or hindered the quality of political debate, and the suggestion is that the effect has been negative, as we have seen in the modern day with the likes of Trump.
David Harewood is Republican William F. Buckley, who famously argued for segregation in a debate with the Black author James Baldwin at the University of Cambridge. In this play his racism isn’t examined particularly closely, and Buckley’s character is softened by his loyalty to and genuine love for his wife. I would have liked to see his views examined more thoroughly, but I do wonder if this was done on purpose to make the conflict with Vidal seem more equal – a modern audience is obviously going to side with the latter. It’s an unexpected and brave choice to have Buckley played by a Black man, but Harewood is superb, perfectly embodying the character of an old-fashioned Republican.
Zachary Quinto plays author and intellectual Gore Vidal, replacing Charles Edwards who took on the role at the Young Vic. With a wealth of celebrity friends and a holiday home in Italy, his views are much more appealing to us but he is exactly the kind of person whom the right wing describe as the “liberal elite”. James Baldwin, who appears as a character in the play, touches on this when he points out that Vidal, when he talks about poverty and racism, is discussing issues that don’t really affect him. He is approaching the subject from a purely intellectual standpoint, just as much as Buckley is. I would have liked to see Edwards in the part, purely because I am a fan, but Quinto is excellent in the role, urbane and polished with a confident self-assurance, until he begins to wonder whether he and Buckley have between them unleashed a kind of monster.
The play, despite being on a topic which would never have attracted my interest if not presented on stage, is gripping throughout and I never felt as though my lack of prior knowledge made a difference to my enjoyment. It’s another triumph for James Graham, and well worth a visit.
Recent Comments