I’m partial to musicals. I like most of the shows I see. I love some of them. But few give me the heart-stopping rush of excitement that characterised my first visits to Phantom and Les Mis. City of Angels belongs to that select few.
I originally saw the show in an amateur production at the Bernie Grant Arts Centre back in March. I thought that a musical inspired by film noir sounded rather intriguing, and I greatly enjoyed the production. I went home, bought the original Broadway cast recording, and over the next few months listened to it over and over, growing steadily more addicted. Then, I found out about Josie Rourke’s new production at the Donmar Warehouse. I managed to nab Barclays Front Row tickets for myself and a friend, and experienced one of the most joyous evenings in the theatre I’ve ever had the fortune to witness.
With music by Cy Coleman, lyrics by David Zippel, and a book by Larry Gelbart, the musical, which premiered on Broadway in 1989, is the story of novelist Stine (Hadley Fraser) who is hired by Hollywood producer Buddy Fidler (Peter Polycarpou) to turn his book City of Angels into a screenplay. However, Stine’s literary style falls foul of Buddy’s cinematic approach – show, don’t tell – and the producer’s constant rewrites and cancelling out of the more challenging political and social themes in the story threaten the writer’s integrity. Meanwhile, Stine’s relationship with his wife Gabby (Rosalie Craig) comes under pressure – largely because of his affair with Buddy’s secretary Donna (Rebecca Trehearn).
As Stine’s life unravels, his screenplay plays out on stage, in a noir tale deeply reminiscent of Raymond Chandler. His protagonist is the hard-boiled detective Stone (Tam Mutu) who is hired by wealthy beauty Alaura (Katherine Kelly) to find her stepdaughter Mallory (Samantha Barks). In an effective visual twist, the “real-life” scenes play in colour while Stone’s world is in black and white. Robert Jones’s simple but effective set design, with movie reels and piles of scripts backing the double-layer set, is the perfect backdrop for Howard Harrison’s lighting design which brings out the differences in the two worlds: nowhere is this used to greater effect than during Stine and Stone’s Act I closing duet, when the worlds collide. The level of detail extends to the props: even Stone’s groceries are black and white. Throughout the show, the two worlds reference and inspire one another; most of the actors in the show play roles in both worlds. Rosalie Craig is Bobbi, Stone’s lost love; Rebecca Trehearn is Oolie, his secretary; Peter Polycarpou plays villainous producer Irvin S. Irving, while Katherine Kelly and Samantha Barks are Hollywood starlets.
Rourke’s production brings clarity to this complex story, introducing the characters at the start and adding little touches which help the story to work. She is aided by a first-class cast. I’ve been a fan of Rosalie Craig since she starred in The Light Princess at the National, and here she brings glamour to the role of Bobbi and confident self-possession to that of Gabby. I loved her Act I rendition of “With Every Breath I Take”, and her sharp, sarcastic “It Needs Work” in Act II. Rebecca Trehearn is a performer new to me, but I loved her: her duet with Rosalie Craig, “What You Don’t Know About Women”, was a highlight, and her solo “You Can Always Count on Me” got some of the biggest applause of the night. Hadley Fraser is superb in the role of the weak, dishevelled writer Stine, while Tam Mutu is perfect for the role of the hard-drinking, wisecracking yet moral Stone. In fact, all of the cast are wonderful, not least the Angel City Four (Sandra Marvin, Jennifer Saayeng, Kadiff Kirwan and Jo Servi) whose singing and little performance touches – glances, expressions, eye rolls – are brilliant and who double up in several small, but key, roles.
The tunes – inspired by jazz and blues – are wonderful, and the lyrics even better. A case in point is Marc Elliot’s magnificent rendition of the Latin-tinged “All You Have To Do Is Wait”. “Adios! The end is close”, his character, vengeful police officer Manny, sings to Stone. Elsewhere, he rhymes “pride” with “cyanide”. Much has been made of the lyric “If you’re not celibate, we could raise hell a bit”, sung by Samantha Barks’ seductive Mallory, but there are plenty of other highlights. “Your pen is no match for my sword”, Stone taunts Stine, and “The Tennis Song”, sung by Stone and Alaura, is laced with innuendo. The book takes inspiration from Raymond Chandler’s one-liners: Stone remarks about Alaura’s legs that “only the floor stopped them from going on forever”.
In addition to all of the above, the show is a thoughtful commentary on stage versus screen and the sacrifice of artistic integrity to commercial values. There is also an extremely topical reference to racial issues: in Stine’s first draft of his screenplay Manny is angry at Stone because as a white man he is able to get away with things that he, Manny, would not. Sound familiar? Buddy makes Stine remove references to “racial stuff” – while surrounded by black workers. “Hey, there’s a person under this skin!” he says to the black masseuse who’s understandably thumped him a little too hard – drawing a gasp from the audience at the sheer irony of it.
I can say with some confidence that City of Angels is my favourite musical. Sorry Phantom and Les Miserables, you’ve got competition. A wonderful production of a brilliant show – I hope I can see it again before it closes.
Recent Comments