“Attend the tale of Sweeney Todd”, sings chorus member Adam Pearce ominously at the beginning of this production, and attend I did, right until the end of the macabre tale of the “Demon Barber of Fleet Street”. Stephen Sondheim’s dark musical, which premiered in 1979 and has enjoyed success in a variety of guises ever since (including a Tim Burton-directed movie starring Johnny Depp and Helena Bonham-Carter), comes to the Adelphi in London fresh from an acclaimed run at the Chichester Festival Theatre. I enjoyed the film and had been looking forward to this production for a while.
As a lover of all things Victoriana, I was disappointed at first to discover that in Jonathan Kent’s production the action has been updated from the nineteenth century to the 1930s, but the effect works very well. Poverty and squalor were still rife in the 20th century and the production conveys its essentially unchanging nature. Swopping gaslight for early electric efforts works well at adding a harsh glare to proceedings and contrasting with the eerie darkness. Some reviewers have complained about the production’s anachronisms – beadles and Bedlam were not in existence by the mid 20th century – but I can’t say that this obviously jarred with me. In any case, if you can set Shakespeare in a different time why not a musical? One thing I wasn’t keen on was the gallery running around the top of the set, occupied largely by the chorus – I was sitting at the very back of the theatre, and while I had a good view overall this gallery was blocked to me.
The two stars of the production, Michael Ball and Imelda Staunton, were both brilliant. I found it hard to imagine Michael Ball in the part, having always seen him as a genial housewives’ favourite, but he was convincing and multi-dimensional as Sweeney Todd. It would be easy to make a caricature of the character, but Ball brings a depth and even sympathy to the man, charting his progress from wronged man bent on revenge against the officials who conspired to part him from his wife, to the chilling serial killer burning with hatred for all mankind. Imelda Staunton as Mrs Lovett played her role for comedy, provoking laughter from the audience on several occasions. You initially see her as a chirpy, warm old lady harbouring a passion for Todd; gradually overtaken by her love of profit and willingness to help him in absolutely any way she can, she becomes increasingly sinister as the production develops.
All of the supporting cast were excellent, particularly John Bowe as the corrupt judge, self-flagellating in a bid to rid himself of the lust he feels for his adopted daughter. Luke Brady as Anthony and Lucy May Barker as Joanna sang and acted very well, but their story was bland and insipid compared to the main plotline of the play. This wasn’t really their fault – their roles were underwritten and there was no resolution to their tale at the end of the show, one of the flaws of the production.
I really liked the way that the show acted as a kind of social commentary. Until he sinks into his role as an indiscriminate serial killer, Todd seeks revenge only on those men who, all those years ago, falsified charges against him in order to steal his wife. I wasn’t sorry to see these characters get their comeuppance. Todd and Mrs Lovett both take delight in the idea that the lower echelons of society will be consuming the rich (albeit in the form of pies), rather than the other way around. The pair’s wickedness forms only part of the “great black pit” of London’s underbelly, in which the helpless are falsely incarcerated in madhouses, supposedly respectable members of society lead hypocritical lives, and the innocent can be punished on trumped-up charges. It is possible to read Mrs Lovett’s decision to turn Sweeney Todd’s victims into pies as a solution, albeit a rather drastic one, to the poverty that she and many other Londoners face.
Much darker than the majority of musicals, Sweeney Todd is nevertheless a thrillingly chilling piece with first-class acting, singing, direction and design, and a great addition to the current London theatre season.
Recent Comments