With fond childhood memories of Alice’s Adventures in Wonderland and Peter Pan, I was intrigued at the prospect of a play about the meeting of Alice Liddell and Peter Lewellyn Davies, the real-life inspirations for the famous title characters of these seminal children’s novels. The meeting really happened – in 1932, when Alice was 80 and Peter 35 – but the content is imagined.
The three principal individuals involved also worked on the latest James Bond film, Skyfall. Playwright John Logan wrote the screenplay, Dame Judi Dench (Alice) played M, and Ben Wishaw (Peter) was introduced as Q. Perhaps this is unsurprising: Peter Pan, Alice and 007 are all British institutions.
The play begins in a gloomy and dusty London bookshop, where Peter and Alice meet and discover each other’s identity: “we are practically our own children’s book department”, remarks Alice. Slowly, the pair open up and share their experiences of childhood, each marked by profound happiness, sadness and a complicated relationship with an intense and difficult writer. As if to reflect their increasingly vivid recollections, the stage itself opens up, revealing in Christopher Oram’s beautiful design a Victorian-style proscenium stage decorated with pictures of Captain Hook and the Mad Hatter and backed, alternately, by scenes of the English countryside and the mermaid’s lagoon in Neverland.
Wordy and complex, the play could have been dull if not for the excellent performances from the two leads. Judi Dench plays Alice as a sharp elderly woman with a grim determination to survive whose expressions and movements soften as she recalls her childhood excursions with Charles Dodgson (Lewis Carroll). Ben Wishaw is the disillusioned Peter, recalling the death of both of his parents from cancer and his resentment at the favouritism James Barrie showed towards his younger brother Michael.
With a supporting cast of actors who portray the youthful book characters and the novelists, the play is about memory and imagination and the unavoidable sadness of growing old. Neither of the book characters comes across as particularly likeable, and the scene in which they taunt their elder real-life counterparts is rather disturbing. The play asks whether taking refuge in the fantastical is a good idea, and seems to conclude that it is: Alice loses herself in her childhood memories and dies peacefully in her bed, an old woman, while Peter concludes otherwise and ends up throwing himself in front of an Underground train at Sloane Square.
This is the second play in the Michael Grandage season at the Noël Coward Theatre, but the first I have seen. I look forward to watching the others.
Recent Comments