The Light in the Piazza is one of those musicals I heard about before it came to the UK, but I still didn’t really know anything about it. I went along to the long-anticipated production at the Royal Festival Hall to see what it was all about. It has a book by Craig Lucas and music and lyrics by Adam Guettel.
Set in 1950s Florence, it stars Renée Fleming and Dove Cameron as an American mother and daughter taking in the sights of Italy. At first Margaret comes across as a typical overprotective mother, uneasy when Clara seems to find happiness with a young Florentine, Fabrizio. However, it soon emerges that Margaret has reason for her concerns. She is hiding a secret about Clara: when her daughter was twelve, she had an accident which affected her mental and emotional development, though this is not necessarily obvious to an outsider. Certainly in the beginning she comes across simply as a naive young girl.
I felt uneasy about this plot development and I couldn’t put my finger on why, until it struck me that Clara’s condition was a way to play up the innocent, childlike female stereotype which fits right in to the 1950s setting. I’m sure it’s possible to write a character like her sensitively and successfully, but I wasn’t convinced here.
Having said that, the performances were superb: Renee Fleming was excellent as Clara’s cynical but loving mother, and Rob Houchen was superb as Fabrizio, with a standout singing voice. Dove Cameron’s character might have been rather insipid but she did a great job with what she had, and her voice too was beautiful. It’s a shame that, for me, the actual music didn’t live up to the quality of the singers and the musicians, with no songs that, for me, were really memorable.
I spent a good deal of time lusting after the costumes: 1950s full skirts and glorious hats. Still, if I wanted to look at costumes I’d go to the Dior exhibition at the V&A. Sadly, for me, the show itself wasn’t particularly memorable.
Recent Comments