The Man Who Had All the Luck was Arthur Miller’s first Broadway play, though it lasted for only four performances back in 1944. This fine revival at the King’s Head Theatre in Islington suggests that it deserves much better than that.
The plot follows garage mechanic David Beeves, who enjoys an impressive run of good luck in his life, marrying his childhood sweetheart despite her father’s opposition, solving a mechanical problem thanks to the timely intervention of a newcomer to the town, and generally experiencing a much more successful life than his younger brother, whom his father has been coaching in baseball for years with the aims of making him into a star. While at first David welcomes his run of luck, as the years go by it starts to become resented by his friends and family, and David himself feels uneasy, feeling convinced that at some point his luck is bound to fail.
The play is an interesting exploration of whether luck or other factors determine your path in life – an examination of the “American Dream”. Interestingly, Miller seems to approach this with more optimism than his later plays would suggest, though this piece certainly foreshadows the themes of his great works, such as family, father-son relationships and the nature of success.
Ably staged by director Paul Lichtenstern, designer Claire Winfield and lighting designer Tom Mowat, the piece is a good fit for the tiny King’s Head, with the audience positioned on three sides of the stage. Despite some dodgy accents, the performances are strong: Jamie Chandler is excellent in the lead role, with Chloe Walshe a good match as his wife Hester. I was also impressed with Peter Dineen, who took on several of the smaller roles in the production (including that of Hester’s imposing father) and made each of them stand out.
I had expected an interesting early curiosity from the writer of The Crucible and Death of a Salesman, but The Man Who Had All the Luck stands up on its own merits – a witty script, perfect pacing and a strong plot make this a must-see for Miller fans.
Recent Comments