Last week, I fulfilled a long-held ambition to see Willy Russell’s Blood Brothers. This show is the third longest-running musical in the West End, after Les Miserables and The Phantom of the Opera, and I thought there must be a reason for this.
The show, originally written in the early Eighties, tells the story of the twin sons of Mrs Johnstone, stuck in the slums of Liverpool with an ever-growing number of children that she struggles to afford to feed. In a moment of desperation she agrees to give one of her twins to her wealthy employer who cannot have children of her own. This boy, named Eddie, grows up surrounded by luxury, is educated at boarding school and university and becomes a councillor, while his twin brother Mickey remains with his mother and siblings, skipping school, and later suffering the effects of unemployment. Against the odds and the wishes of their parents, the brothers meet as children and form a lifelong bond – swearing allegiance as ‘blood brothers’ – but the effects of superstition and their contrasting backgrounds conspire to tragic effect.
I really wanted to like this musical. It has been running for a long time and always sounded like the sort of thing I would enjoy. The central role of Mrs Johnstone in particular has been played by stars including Melanie Chisholm and Natasha Hamilton. Mrs Johnstone certainly has the most pivotal role and the best songs. Vivienne Carlyle, who played her in this production, was excellent – warm, likeable and believable.
David Cooper and Simon Willmont, who played the twins Mickey and Eddie, were very good too. They both had difficult jobs as they had to act as seven-year-olds, teenagers and young adults. I did think the show as a whole spent too much time on the twins when they were young as I thought it got a little tedious. The supporting cast seemed good – there were no obvious outstanding actors or bad ones.
Marti Pellow from the band Wet Wet Wet played the Narrator, who remains on stage throughout the performance. I wasn’t particularly excited about this as I never liked the band, but his singing and acting was good. Through no fault of his, I really disliked the character of the Narrator. When he isn’t standing on the sidelines observing the action with a disapproving gaze, he is yelling in the ears of Mrs Johnstone or Mrs Lyons, singing things like “See what a BAD thing you’ve done? Don’t think you’ve escaped. The DEVIL will be knocking on your door soon”, etc, etc. While it’s true that the first scene tells you what’s going to happen, this doesn’t mean that I want it rammed down my throat at every opportunity. I think the show would have been much better without the Narrator at all.
There was something I really didn’t like about Blood Brothers. The Liverpool working class setting seemed incongruous with the style of music. I was expecting something along the lines of the marvellous Billy Elliot, but some parts of this show unintentionally made me want to laugh. It took itself so seriously and struck me as rather dated, unlike the other shows that came out at the same time.
All in all I was rather disappointed with Blood Brothers. I did enjoy it, but it seemed rather silly in parts and the Narrator really got on my nerves. The songs, apart from Mrs Johnstone’s, weren’t particularly memorable. Still, I’m glad I’ve seen it at last.
Recent Comments