I have a confession to make. I have a bit of a thing about dead poets. Most particularly Lord Byron, famously “mad, bad and dangerous to know”. Therefore I just had to see Howard Brenton’s 1984 play Bloody Poetry, revived by Tom Littler at the tiny Jermyn Street Theatre.
The play tells the story of the famous quartet of Byron, Percy Bysshe Shelley, Mary Shelley (nee Godwin) and Claire Clairmont. The first act covers the summer they spent together at the Villa Diodati in 1816, during which Byron and Shelley shared ideas on poetry, philosophy and life, and Mary got the idea for her novel Frankenstein. The play really captures the sense of optimism and desire for revolution felt by this young group of exiles. The second act is darker, with the presence of a ghostly Harriet Westbrook (Shelley’s first wife) haunting Shelley as tragedy besets his life.
A play about a bunch of poets sitting around musing on life could easily have been dull or pretentious, but this is not the case, in part down to the quality of the actors. David Sturzacker perfectly captures Byron’s arrogance and cynicism, interspersed with the flashes of generosity and depth of feeling which make him such a fascinating character. If this play has a protagonist, however, then it is Shelley – the story follows his household, wanderings and eventual death – and Joe Bannister portrays him with the air of otherworldliness and passion that makes him believable as the author of The Mask of Anarchy and other works, quoted in the play.
As characters, the women often come across better. Rhiannon Sommers as the imaginative and resolute Mary puts on a good performance, as does Joanna Christie as the naïve but strong and determined Claire. Emily Glenister only has a small role as Shelley’s first wife, but makes a strong impression – her presence is eerie and unsettling.
A special mention must go to Nick Trumble as Polidori, Byron’s personal physician and the butt of many a joke throughout the play. Lacking the imagination, intelligence and passion of the rest of the group, his character inspires pity but also revulsion and his bitter soliloquies bring home how unique the play’s protagonists were.
I really enjoyed the interactions between the characters. At one point Byron wonders what life would be like if he and Shelley ran off together to live away from society. The interesting thing is that I could completely imagine this odd couple together, no matter how different they clearly were. They clearly had a lot of respect and liking for one another, but their strong differences in character made for entertaining conversation, not least when they were discussing Wordsworth. No less interesting was the relationship between stepsisters Mary and Claire. Their love and sympathy for one another remained even in spite of their complicated ménage-a-trois with Shelley.
If I could go back to any time and place in history, the summer of 1816 by Lake Geneva would be it. As time travel hasn’t been invented yet, this is the next best thing. I found the play fascinating to watch and illuminating in its exploration of poetical and philosophical ideals.