After enjoying a previous Alan Ayckbourn play, Absent Friends, I was looking forward to seeing A Chorus of Disapproval at the Harold Pinter Theatre. Despite being in two minds whether I would like it, I actually thoroughly enjoyed the play.
This 1984 play about the off-stage antics of an amateur dramatic group involved in a production of The Beggar’s Opera has been revived and directed by Trevor Nunn. It is a complex production, and confusing to begin with: it opens at the end of the production, with the star cast member ostracised by the rest of the cast, and then goes back in time to find out how this state of affairs happened. Once the tedious introductions are over and the widowed newcomer is accepted into the cast, things start to happen and the play became greatly entertaining, as well as superbly plotted.
I really liked Nigel Harman’s performance as newcomer Guy Jones. Initially he is as dull as his name, quiet and wearing a Roy Cropper-like anorak, but as the play progresses he sheds the anorak, straightens up and gains in confidence, mirrored in the play-within-a-play as he moves from the tiny role of Crook-Fingered Jack to the major part of Macheath. His appealing naivety, which initially endears him to two of the women in the group – embroiling him in a triangle mirroring that of The Beggar’s Opera – turns against him when the cast members’ requests for insider knowledge about a land deal come to a head.
The standout performance for me in a good cast came from Rob Brydon as proudly Welsh am-dram director Dafydd ap Llewellyn, whose easily irritated, abrasive character also evoked sympathy. The large cast offered strong support, particularly Georgia Brown as Bridget the stage manager, and Ashley Jensen and Daisy Beaumont as Guy’s lovers.
I thought most of the play’s humour was smile-provoking rather than laughter-inducing, but there were some very funny moments, especially the scene in which Guy visits swinger Fay and confuses her overtures with references to their forthcoming meal. The moment when Guy and Hannah break up in the middle of a lighting check is extremely well choreographed, and Dafydd’s realisation that he has just broadcast his marital troubles over the tannoy is tragically funny.
Though I thought the play could have been shorter, and the beginning was rather slow, I was pleasantly surprised by how much I enjoyed it, and would recommend seeing the show.