I’ve seen several Terence Rattigan plays over the last few years, and was eager to see this production of The Winslow Boy at the always-impressive Old Vic. Directed by Lindsay Posner, this 1946 play is set in 1913-14 and manages to capture an Edwardian society on the brink of change.
Based on a real-life story, the play is about a naval cadet expelled for supposedly stealing a five-shilling postal order, and his father’s long fight for justice at the cost of his own health and his family’s financial security. It’s a long play, staged traditionally in a middle-class drawing room, and moves at a slow pace; yet it remains compelling throughout.
Despite the play’s title, we see little of the ‘Boy’ – the youngest Winslow child Ronnie – and the central character is undoubtedly his father Arthur, superbly played by Henry Goodman, who captures the character’s warmth and belief in justice while still allowing us to understand why his children are – initially at least – scared of him. The play concentrates on him and the lives of his elder son Dickie (Nick Hendrix) and suffragette daughter Catherine (Naomi Frederick), who both suffer from their father’s fight to clear their brother’s name – Dickie is forced to leave university, while Catherine’s fiancé breaks off their engagement after pressure from his own father. Peter Sullivan comes to the play relatively late, but makes up for this with his fine performance as renowned barrister Sir Robert Morton, whose explosive confrontation with Ronnie is one of the best first-act closing scenes I’ve ever witnessed. His verbal spars with Catherine, in which the two develop a mutual respect despite widely opposing political views, are highlights of the play.
In a way, the play is very much of its time – seemingly conventional and slow-moving, it is wordy and thoughtful. However, in other ways it is surprisingly up to date – Arthur Winslow’s fight for his son could be interpreted as a modern attack on politicians seeking to do away with human rights legislation, while the cynical view of the media – when Arthur asks Morton what comment he should make to the journalists hovering around his front door, Morton replies, “I hardly think it matters. Whatever you say will have little bearing on what they write” – speaks directly to a 21st-century audience.
Surprisingly funny in parts, the play ends on a poignant note with the suggestion that Arthur Winslow’s fight has cost him his health and may ultimately cost him his life. There is, too, a realisation on the part of the audience that it may have all been for nothing – with World War I just around the corner, both of Winslow’s sons will be faced with the horrors of war (and in fact, the real-life boy who inspired the play was killed in the trenches in 1914). It is a sad postscript, and it is striking that the indifference of the Government towards Ronnie’s plight foreshadows the later suffering of thousands of individuals by order of the state.