The James Plays is a series of plays by Rona Munro looking at the first three kings of Scotland named James. I saw all three plays in one day – an exhilarating experience that allowed me to appreciate the complexity of this huge undertaking. The plays are thrilling powerful and packed with memorable characters, following themes such as the nature of power and Scottish nationalism. The set of the Olivier stage is sparse except for the large sword thrust through the surface – a stark reminder of the importance of war during the period. A throne sits at the back of the stage, high up beside the stage seats.
James I: The Key Will Keep the Lock opens with the English King Henry V (Jamie Sives) goading his prisoner, King James of Scotland (James McArdle). Kicking off with Henry was an inspired choice – audiences might not be familiar with the early kings of Scotland, but they will surely be aware of Henry, and should be better able to place the plays in their historical context. Released from captivity, James attempts to regain authority, facing difficulties from powerful nobles and from his young English wife, Joan (Stephanie Hyam). Seeing King James grow in stature acting against the nobles who oppose him, and asserting his authority, is gripping stuff, tempered by his complex relationship with his sharp but vulnerable wife.
James II: Day of the Innocents is very different: we see a puppet version of the child king, controlled by rival nobles after his father’s early death. It is nightmarish and troubling, a world where no one can be trusted. And yet, there is hope: a grown-up James (Andrew Rothney) makes decisions, deals with the nobles, and makes sure that everyone knows who is the boss. Apart from the political intrigue, there is an interesting sub-plot involving James and his close friendship with William Douglas (Mark Rowley); Douglas comforts James in his childhood fear, but as the king grows up, takes responsibility and marries, the relationship between the pair grows strained, with tragic consequences.
The third play, James III: The True Mirror, is even more different – characters wear modern-style dress and dance, before the production begins, to twenty-first century pop hits in a joyful celebration. King James III (Jamie Sives, unrecognisable from his earlier role as Henry V) is selfish, unreliable, vain and thoughtless, meaning that his wife, Queen Margaret (Sofie Gråbøl), undertakes much of the running of the country. This James also asserts his authority, but unlike the previous two, he asserts his right to ignore the country and do exactly what he likes – admirable in many ways, even if not so good for Scotland. It is left to Margaret to rule in his stead while the future James IV is young.
These plays are a huge achievement: Munro’s writing is pacy, sharp and very funny, revealing truths about the Scottish character and getting right to the heart of what matters. Director Laurie Sansom ensures that the energy that powers the plays never falters, and the cast is uniformly excellent, with no weak links. The three kings are all three-dimensional characters, with Jamie Sives particularly good at making his character sympathetic despite his clear unsuitability as a monarch. Stephanie Hyam is excellent as the first two Scottish queens, who are completely different from one another. And Sofie Gråbøl is superb as Queen Margaret, who, with her rousing speech about the Scots at the end of the third play, ends the trilogy on a feminist high.
The James Plays are sure to go down as one of my highlights of 2014. They are particularly relevant in the context of the recent referendum, but there is enough fascinating history and brilliant characterisation here to make the plays timeless.