Douglas Adams once claimed that the meaning of life was 42, so it seems fitting that a show about the magic of Broadway and the power it has over so many people happens to be named 42nd Street. It is an old-school Broadway musical with a book by Michael Stewart and Mark Bramble, lyrics by Al Dubin, and music by Harry Warren. Based on the 1932 novel by Bradford Ropes and the subsequent 1933 film adaptation, it premiered in London in 1984 and has enjoyed a number of West End and Broadway revivals since. This touring production is the first chance I’ve had to see the musical.
The plot is fairly predictable: a young woman arrives in New York dreaming of stardom, and ends up joining the chorus of notorious producer Julian Marsh’s new show, Pretty Lady. After an accident incapacitates the resident prima donna Dorothy, Peggy – the new chorus girl – is persuaded to take on the leading role. Will she master the part in time?
I wasn’t sure about this show at first, partly because the sound in the theatre seemed to be a bit off, and this distracted me. However, the performances – including those of Matthew J. Taylor as Julian, Caitlin Ehlinger as Peggy and Kaitlin Lawrence as Dorothy, won me over. Some of the songs were a tad forgettable but others were particularly memorable, including the title song, a celebration of the magic of Broadway that I can totally get on board with.
The staging was fairly basic, but this is to be expected from a touring production. It worked well and did the job in any case. I did enjoy the bigger dancing scenes in which the whole cast participated: these were really impressive.
Though predictable, the show had moments of real feeling and a melancholic ending that I hadn’t expected and that raised it in my estimation. I doubt that 42nd Street will enter my list of top musicals, but it’s another show to tick off my list and an evening well spent.