I’ve often thought it might be cool to go to Glyndebourne, though I’ve been put off by the thought that it’s probably way too posh for me. I suppose the next best thing is The Moderate Soprano, David Hare’s new play which premiered at the Hampstead Theatre and has now found it’s way to The Duke of York’s.
The play tells the story of how rich eccentric John Christie and his wife Audrey Mildmay, the ‘moderate soprano’ of the title, founded Glyndebourne, creating a new opera tradition in Britain, a country that had traditionally been without one. Hare shows that, despite Glyndebourne’s reputation as an English institution, it was largely shaped by a group of German and Austrian refugees who came over in the 1930s: conductor Fritz Busch, director Carl Ebert and intendant Rudolf Bing.
This aspect of the play lifts it from being ‘merely’ a work about opera. Christie is exceptionally naive, so focused on his dream that he barely noticed how the Nazis were growing in power during his many trips to Germany. He responds to the émigré’s accounts of their treatment under Hitler with gentle disbelief, as if such things could not possibly happen; an attitude all too common even today when we are confronted with human rights abuses. Christie’s leadership is subtly compared and contrasted with Hitler’s, as Busch, Ebert and Bing are forced to work under someone who, while he is a much better person than Hitler, is similarly unwilling to allow them their creative freedom.
The play is a fascinating study of how a near-impossible dream became a reality. It is often very funny, thanks largely to Roger Allam’s superb performance as the affable John Christie, and some brilliant lines. “He may be great,” Christie remarks on Mozart, who is not his favourite composer, “but is he any good?” It’s impossible not to get caught up in his enthusiasm and clear love for opera, even to the extent of making it as difficult as possible to arrive at and leave the theatre so that people will appreciate it.
It’s also a study of a marriage, the touching relationship between John and Audrey (the superb Nancy Carroll) sensitively portrayed. Hare shows how Audrey was able to mediate between John and his musical colleagues, and she made an important contribution to early Glyndebourne history by performing in many of its early Mozart productions.
If anything, seeing this play has made me want to go to Glyndebourne even more. I suppose I’d better start playing the lottery.