As is tradition, I went to the theatre on the second of January: a treat to look forward to after the first day back at work. This year, my choice of show was the much-anticipated Company.
Originally staged in 1970, Sondheim’s well-known musical centred on Bobby, a single man celebrating his 35th birthday, questioning love and relationships while surrounded by friends who are all coupled up. This production revolutionises things by making Bobby into a woman – Bobbie – a move which I think makes sense in 2019.
Bobbie is played by Rosalie Craig, a performer I’ve loved for years, and she’s every bit as good as I’d expected. Her Bobbie is a confident and determined woman, with no shortage of admirers or partners, but none of them seem destined to become ‘The One’. As she turns 35 she begins to question this; there are moments of vulnerability in songs like ‘Being Alive’, but there are contrasting moments like the encounter with pleasant but dim flight attendant Andy (Richard Fleeshman), in which she envisions a somewhat nightmarish vision of her potential future with this man.
What I loved about the musical was it’s appreciation of the complexity of love and relationships, and Sondheim’s refusal to deliver easy answers. This is most apparent in songs like ‘The Little Things You Do Together’ and ‘Marry Me A Little’, as well as the marriage of Sarah and Harry (an excellent Mel Giedroyc and Gavin Spokes) and the commitment phobia of Jamie (Jonathan Bailey), who, terrified at his impending marriage to Paul, delivers a hilarious rendition of ‘Not Getting Married Today’. (Having the character of Amy reimagined as Jamie is also a feature of the 2018 production: interesting that this gay couple, for whom marriage is a recent phenomenon, is shown to experience the same kind of commitment phobia that has plagued heterosexual couples for centuries).
There’s an ‘Alice in Wonderland’ quality to Marianne Elliott’s inventive staging and Bunny Christie’s inventive design, with Bobbie moving through boxes as they travel across the stage, crawling under tables and over chairs as she navigates her world. The timing of the events of the show is also somewhat vague: does Bobbie’s birthday party, which plays out in three very different scenes in the musical, take place before, after or during everything else that goes on? Is it, even all in her head? If Bobbie is Alice, then Joanne, played by incomparable Broadway star Patti LuPone, is definitely the Queen of Hearts, with a powerful rendition of ‘Ladies Who Lunch’.
Ultimately, I was left unsure about the message of the show. Bobbie, moving through her life in a standout red dress, seems to be having a better time than any of her friends, which is somewhat at odds with her desire to find a partner. And it might be one of the best songs in the show, but ultimately I reject the message of ‘Being Alive’. “Alone is alone, not alive,” is something I fundamentally disagree with.