I had the day off work the other week and decided to go to a matinee performance of The Starry Messenger. I was rather glad to be able to make a matinee, knowing that the play was going to be approximately three hours long.
The Nineties-set play, written by Kenneth Lonergan (better known for hit movie Manchester by the Sea), stars Matthew Broderick as Mark, an astronomy professor who teaches night classes at New York’s Hayden Planetarium. He has a comfortable home life, with a loving wife, Anne (Elizabeth McGovern), and a teenage son, but his life is shaken up when he falls in love with a young woman, Angela (Rosalind Eleazar), whose son has an interest in astronomy.
I did wonder if this was going to be one of those familiar stories where an older man (usually a professor) has a midlife crisis and has an affair with a younger woman. In many ways it is, but there is more to it. Angela – a single mother working hard to qualify as a nurse – has a presence and a life of her own, and some of the most memorable scenes in the play take place in the hospital where she works, in a room with one of her patients. When tragedy strikes, Angela is forced to question everything, and Mark is left with a sadness he can’t explain to his family.
Lighthearted moments are provided by the students in Mark’s astronomy class, particularly Sid Sagar as an overzealous student keen to grade Mark on every aspect of his teaching. Elizabeth McGovern is underused as Anne but Sinead Matthews and Jim Norton are well-rounded characters who feature in a fascinating subplot.
I can’t say this was a favourite play of mine, and I did think it was far too long, but it offered some thought-provoking moments.