The RSC’s long-delayed production of The Comedy of Errors is finally here, performed in a new outdoor space next to the Swan Theatre. I confess this play is not my favourite of Shakespeare’s works, but Philip Breen’s new production – presented over a year after it was originally meant to premiere in the Royal Shakespeare Theatre – is possibly the best I’ve seen.
The plot is silly even by Shakespearean standards: two sets of twins are separated soon after birth, each parent keeping hold of one of each pair (although the mother is soon separated from the children once again). Thirty years later, Antipholus of Syracuse and his servant Dromio travel to Ephesus to find their long-lost brothers, unaware that Antipholus’ father Egeon is under sentence of death. Confusion and farce ensues as Antipholus is continually mistaken for his twin brother, who is settled in Ephesus, and vice versa; the two Dromios are similarly confused for one another. This plot has frustrated me greatly in the past – why doesn’t Antipholus of Syracuse at least suspect something is up (his brother, unaware that he has a twin, has some excuse for his confusion)? This production, for the first time, managed to transform my frustration into amusement and interest.
There is much that is farcical, plenty of slapstick: there is a prolonged toupee joke involving a waiter fairly early on, which had the audience in stitches; the beginning of the second act features an amusing sketch involving a giant ribbon and an oversized pair of scissors. Later, as the visiting Antipholus and Dromio are threatened, they hastily unwrap one of their many parcels to reveal a kitchen knife set which they unpack and brandish. It’s not all cartoonish violence, though: when Antipholus strikes Dromio in frustration, there is a silence, as if everyone there knows he has crossed some sort of line.
Set in the Eighties, in a Middle Eastern setting that makes me think of modern day Dubai or Quatar, it’s apparent that the wealthy cosmopolitan atmosphere of Ephesus has a darker undertone: perhaps the presence of a disease akin to Covid (actors boldly apply hand sanitiser at several points) or a military or government threat. The descent of Antipholus of Ephesus into madness is shown to be genuinely frightening for both him and the people around him.
The cast embrace the anarchy enthusiastically: Guy Lewis and Rowan Polonski do a great job as the twins named Antipholus and Jonathan Broadbent and Greg Haiste are also excellent as their servants, Dromio. Also worth a particular mention are William Grint as 2nd Merchant and Dyfrig Morris as his bodyguard – intergrating British Sign Language into the production in a way the RSC have done to excellent effect in recent productions.
As the play comes to a close, misunderstandings are cleared up and the family is reunited: a moving scene given the family separations that have proved necessary in the past year. It’s hardly happily ever after – Antipholus of Ephesus gives his brother a look that speaks volumes – but it’s something of a return to normality.