I was excited at the prospect of seeing Player Kings, particularly as Sir Ian McKellen was starring as Falstaff, but also because I’ve really enjoyed Robert Icke’s work in the past and was looking forward to seeing his take on Henry IV Parts 1 and 2. Shakespeare’s two great history plays have been combined into one in this epic production, which is so long it kicks off at six thirty in the evening instead of the more usual half past seven, and lasts over three hours. However, as is the case with the best theatre, the running time isn’t at all a slog.
As is to be expected, McKellen is great in his role, hamming it up as the legendary Falstaff. His take on the character, on the surface a harmless if lazy drunkard, reveals a grotesque old man, a coward and manipulator of the truth. There is little doubt that he is a distinctly unpleasant person.
In most productions, Falstaff is held up to us as an example of someone who is not honourable, while the young Prince Henry – eventually King Henry V – grapples with the concept of honour and eventually grows to become someone possessing this quality. Here, what I found interesting was the idea that Henry was not necessarily honourable himself. One moment at the climax of the first half, which had the audience gasping in shock, sees Prince Henry walking up behind his enemy Harry Hotspur, and stabbing him in the back – this is after Hotspur has repeatedly allowed his rival to rise from the floor to continue the fight, instead of attacking him while he is down.
As Henry – Prince Hal – Toheeb Jimoh is excellent – a star in the making. He is charismatic, flawed, enjoying life free from responsibility but keen to prove himself to his stern, strict father (Richard Coyle). Samuel Edward-Cook plays Hotspur, the volatile, warlike son of Northumberland, against whom Henry is measured by the king and found wanting.
The production is in modern dress, which suits the world created by Icke with a stark brick set by Hildegard Bechtler. One scene featuring debates and negotiations among the nobility is shown as a telephone conversation as if in split screen, which I liked. There is a stark contrast between the austere world of the court and the grubby setting of Mistress Quickly’s inn.
The first half is much more exciting than the second, which is no surprise – Henry IV Part I was always more enjoyable than its sequel. However, it does have several enjoyable moments, including Falstaff being awarded medals for his supposed heroics on the battlefield, and Prince Hal’s reconciliation with his father on his deathbed.
Don’t be put off by the length of this play – Player Kings is a worthy addition to the recent run of Shakespeares in the West End and a must see for any fans of McKellen.