What with Noises Off, One Man, Two Guvnors and now What the Butler Saw, farce has been enjoying something of a revival lately. I believe farces are so popular for the same reason there is currently such a plethora of vintage musicals in theWest End: pure escapism in a world of recession, government cuts and all-round misery. This 1967 play by Joe Orton offers a head-spinning, manic night out.
I’m not familiar with the works of Joe Orton, and I only know two things about him: that he was brutally murdered by his lover (before he had a chance to revise this, his final play) and that he is notorious for defacing several library books in Islington. Judging by the title of this piece I’d imagined it was set in a Downton Abbey-esque stately home, but it is in fact set in a psychiatric clinic, where Dr Prentice’s attempt to seduce his new secretary sets in motion a chain of events also involving his wife, a government official, a bellboy from the nearby Station Hotel, and a policeman. Mistaken identities, cross-dressing and frequent frenzied slamming of doors are the order of the day, until neither the cast nor the audience are entirely sure who is mad and who is sane.
Sean Foley’s production has largely received poor reviews, which surprised me as I really enjoyed myself – although in fairness I have no other productions to compare it to. Old-fashioned it may be, but I rather enjoy farce. It requires real commitment from all involved: everyone needs to come on at exactly the right time, and everything has to run like clockwork. Not to mention the difficulties involved in writing and staging it in the first place.
What the Butler Saw is rather dated, with some unpleasant jokes and old-fashioned innuendo, but, this aside, is really rather funny. Dr Prentice’s (Tim McInnerny) frantic attempts to keep on top of things are brilliantly daft, while Samantha Bond has some fantastic moments as his wife, such as when she sways, drunk, towards a vase holding a bunch of flowers, perching precariously on her stilettos. The whole thing is utterly absurd, particularly the closing scenes, but entertaining nevertheless. For all the humour, however, the play has some darker undercurrents, such as the secretary (Georgia Moffett) certified insane and shorn of her locks by the mad Dr Rance (Omid Djalili) and the policeman drugged, undressed, and left under a garden shrubbery.
The play’s social commentary and subversion of authority does not go unnoticed: the government official Dr Rance, epigrammatically declaring “You can’t be a rationalist in an irrational world. It isn’t rational”, is a Gogolesque example of a corrupt authority figure, and Dr Prentice is hardly a pillar of society. Orton is possessed of a Wildean wit, endowing his characters with brilliant lines such as Dr Prentice’s “There is nothing furtive in my relationship with the editor of the Guardian” and his wife’s cutting remark, “My uterine contractions have been bogus for some time”.
Overall, despite the critical reviews I would recommend this play as a funny, sharp if slightly dated evening of slightly mad entertainment.
Recent Comments