I’ve seen The Last Five Years on stage before, as well as the movie version, but this Southwark Playhouse production – recently transferred to the Garrick Theatre – got such good reviews that I decided to check it out, too. The show tells the story of the relationship between New Yorkers Cathy and Jamie, but with a twist: he tells his story chronologically, she tells hers in reverse. Thus, the show begins with a devastated Cathy shocked at the end of her marriage, while an optimistic Jamie sings about the hot new girl he has just met. By the end, Cathy is innocently excited about her burgeoning new relationship, while a sadder and wiser Jamie is forced to confront his own behaviour. The pair meet only in the middle, at their wedding – a bittersweet occasion, given we know what’s coming.
The two performers are wonderful: Molly Lynch a warm, sympathetic, self-deprecating Cathy, Oli Higginson a cocky, swaggering Jamie. The two bring additional depth to their characters – Lynch suggests that Cathy’s lack of confidence stands in the way of the relationship from the beginning, while Higginson brings a vulnerability and generosity to Jamie that makes this rather arseholey character more sympathetic. Oh, and their singing is brilliant. Some of the songs are more memorable than others, but they all work together to tell the story.
Jonathan O’Boyle’s production helps to cover some of the flaws in the musical – the simple set, featuring a piano which each of the actors at some point plays, allows the performers to interact with a glance, a look, even as they occupy different points in time. I admit I don’t often notice the lighting in theatres, but it worked so well here – the abiding image that will stay with me is the final scene, in which Cathy, excited about her future, is bathed in a golden glow while Jamie, in a darker place, is illuminated with cold blue light.
I gave this production a standing ovation – The Last Five Years might not be the greatest musical ever, but this production is first class.